NoPII

Nightfall vs Skyflow: 2026 Comparison of Pricing and Architecture

Choose Nightfall to stop data leaking through people and tools, choose Skyflow if you need a governed vault that decides who sees real values, and look at Enigma Vault NoPII if you only need PII kept out of your own app’s LLM calls.

AK Abhilash Kumar Nov 22, 2026 16 min read
On this page

    Enigma Vault

    Secure your cards.
    Protect your data.
    Keep it out of your AI.

    Data tokenization that keeps your applications working, so a breach exposes nothing worth stealing.

    • Free Lite tier, no contract
    • PCI DSS Level 1, SOC 2 Type II
    • Billed through AWS Marketplace
    Request a demo

    Nightfall and Skyflow are both sensitive-data platforms for AI-heavy companies that keep PII, PHI, and secrets away from the wrong people, tools, and models.

    Nightfall is best for security teams that want to detect and stop data leaking through employees, SaaS apps, and AI tools, while Skyflow is best for enterprises that want sensitive values stored in one governed vault, with every other system holding tokens.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow at a Glance

    VendorNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    Best forSecurity teams stopping data loss across employees, SaaS apps, and AI toolsEnterprises that need one governed home for PII, PHI, and card data, including what AI seesProduct teams keeping PII out of one app’s LLM calls
    Entry pricePer user per year, by quoteQuote onlyFree, then $49/mo
    Free optionProof of value; no self-serve trialFree Try Account, test data onlyFree Lite tier: 1M protected tokens a month
    ArchitectureDetect-and-redact DLP, with an endpoint agent and integrationsData privacy vault, with de-identification and re-identificationLLM privacy proxy, with token restore in the response
    G24.6/5 (101)5.0/5 (2)5.0/5 (1)
    Capterra5.0/5 (2)No listingNo listing
    Next stepFree Lite tier, no card needed. Published plans from $49 a month.

    Figures are as of 22 November 2026, from each vendor’s site, docs, and terms, except G2 and Capterra figures, read on 22 November 2026. For a wider shortlist, see our guides to Nightfall alternatives and Skyflow alternatives.

    This guide compares Nightfall and Skyflow on architecture, features, cost at three business sizes, compliance, and reviews, with Enigma Vault NoPII alongside as a third option for teams that only need to protect one application’s LLM traffic.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow: Quick Verdict

    Nightfall: An AI-native DLP platform sold in two editions. Foundation covers 12 API-integrated SaaS apps (including Google Drive, Gmail, Slack, Microsoft Teams, OneDrive, SharePoint, Exchange Online, Jira, Confluence, Zendesk, Salesforce, and Notion), an endpoint agent for browsers, desktop apps, and AI apps, shadow AI prevention, and an autonomous analyst called Nyx.

    Premier adds AI agent security: hooks for Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code, MCP discovery, an MCP gateway, and Claude Enterprise monitoring. Both editions are priced per user per year, by quote.

    Skyflow: A data privacy vault that now leads with “Runtime AI Data Control” for datastores, models, and agents. Sensitive values live in the vault, your systems hold tokens, and policy decides who gets real values back. Its de-identification service covers 60 entity types in more than 40 languages, across text, files, audio, and images, and it sells vaults for PII, PHI, payments, and data residency. It publishes no prices.

    Also consider

    Enigma Vault NoPII: A proxy in front of your LLM API calls. Data is tokenized before it reaches the model provider and restored in the response, with a base-URL change, a free tier of one million protected tokens a month, and published plans from $49 to $499 a month.

    Nightfall fits you if:

    • Your risk is people: employees pasting customer data into ChatGPT, uploading files to personal drives, or posting secrets in Slack.
    • Your developers use Cursor, Claude Code, or VS Code, and you need to see which MCP servers they connect and what flows through them.
    • You want alerts, blocking, and in-the-moment coaching managed by a security team.

    Skyflow fits you if:

    • Your risk is storage: PII, PHI, or card numbers copied across databases, warehouses, logs, and AI pipelines.
    • You need the original values kept, with different views for different roles and data held in specific countries.
    • Card data and PCI DSS Level 1 scope are part of the project, and you have an enterprise buying process.

    Enigma Vault NoPII fits you if:

    • One product sends customer text to OpenAI, Anthropic, or another provider, and you want PII tokenized on the way out and restored on the way back.
    • You want a published price and a free tier you can test on real traffic.
    • You can live without employee monitoring, SaaS scanning, and file and audio handling.

    Bottom Line: Nightfall watches where data goes, Skyflow controls where data lives, and Enigma Vault NoPII gives product teams without an enterprise security budget a way to keep PII out of their own model calls for free to start.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow Pricing

    What Nightfall Charges

    Nightfall’s pricing page shows the shape of its plans with the amounts left blank. Foundation Edition is priced per user per year and covers SaaS, email, AI apps, and endpoints.

    Premier Edition is also per user per year and adds AI agent security, in two tiers: up to three supported apps, or all supported apps. Each user license includes two endpoint devices, and more are sold at the same annual rate.

    Every plan includes 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning, with annual add-ons at 1 TB, 3 TB, 5 TB, and 20 TB. There is no self-serve trial, only a proof of value.

    Nightfall’s help center also describes a Developer API with a free plan of 3 GB of scanned data a month and custom Enterprise pricing above that. The edition pricing page does not mention it, so confirm the current API terms with Nightfall.

    What Skyflow Charges

    Skyflow publishes no plans or prices, and its homepage offers only “Get a Demo” and “Contact Sales.” Its Terms of Service, updated 15 July 2026, tell you more about cost than any pricing page.

    Skyflow termWhat it says
    Pricing unitFees are calculated on Unique Identifiers, such as a person, entity, or account number, with true-up charges if you exceed the contracted count
    Billing and renewalInvoiced annually in advance, with a 5% increase at renewal
    Detection warrantyNo warranty that detection finds all PII, or that re-identification returns identical data
    Try AccountFree, for test data only; Skyflow staff may access the data, the data processing addendum does not apply, and PHI, PCI, and other regulated data are not allowed
    LiabilityCapped at fees paid in the prior 12 months
    Compare: Enigma Vault NoPII has a free Lite tier and published plans of $49, $249, and $499 a month.

    Nightfall does not publish an equivalent customer agreement on its pricing page. Its published plan details include a dedicated customer success manager and priority support with a one-hour SLA, so ask for the master agreement early, particularly the clauses on how long scanned content and findings are kept.

    What Enigma Vault NoPII Charges

    Enigma Vault NoPII

    Every Enigma Vault NoPII tier is published, billed on protected tokens flowing through the proxy. Lite is free for one million a month, Starter is $49 for 50 million, Growth is $249 for 500 million, and Business is $499 for 2 billion, with yearly prices of $550, $2,700, and $5,500. Enterprise is custom and includes the self-hosted edition.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow Cost at Three Business Sizes

    Business sizeNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    Startup or single product teamFoundation by quote, per user, after a proof of valueQuote on Unique Identifiers; the Try Account is for test data only$0 on Lite, or $49/mo on Starter
    Growing company with a company-wide rolloutPer user, plus extra endpoints and data add-onsQuote, invoiced annually in advance$249/mo on Growth, or $2,700 a year
    Enterprise with AI agents and regulated dataPremier by quote, tiered by number of coding appsQuote; dedicated VPC or your own cloud$499/mo on Business, or Enterprise for self-hosting
    Next stepNeither vendor publishes amounts. Model your own users, records, and LLM traffic.

    How to Read This Table: The units are different. Nightfall’s bill grows with headcount and devices, Skyflow’s grows with the number of people or accounts whose data you store, and Enigma Vault NoPII’s grows with LLM traffic. A 500-person company with ten million customer records would see a modest Nightfall seat count and a large Skyflow identifier count; a 5,000-person company with few customers would see the reverse.

    The Practical Takeaway: Ask Nightfall for a quote at your real user and device count, and ask Skyflow exactly how it counts Unique Identifiers for your data model, including duplicates across systems. Then add the 5% renewal uplift to Skyflow’s second year before you compare.

    A full year of Enigma Vault NoPII Growth costs $2,700, which gives you a published baseline for the LLM part of the job. See our list of the best PII tokenization software for LLMs for more price points.

    How Nightfall and Skyflow Differ at the Core

    Nightfall assumes sensitive data will spread and watches for it wherever it shows up, whereas Skyflow assumes sensitive data should stay in one place and hands every other system a token. That one choice shapes what each can see, what happens to the original value, and what you maintain.

    QuestionNightfall AI (detect-and-redact DLP)Skyflow (data privacy vault)Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII (LLM privacy proxy)
    How data is protectedDetected in SaaS apps, endpoints, and AI tools, then blocked, redacted, coached, or alertedStored in the vault; your systems keep tokensTokenized in the LLM request as it passes through the proxy
    What happens to the original valueGone if redacted; kept only if you encrypt with your own RSA keyKept in the vault and re-identified by role and policyRestored in the response; reveals limited by grant
    What it seesLaptops, browsers, and integrated SaaS appsThe applications and data platforms you integrateYour apps’ LLM API calls
    RolloutEndpoint agent through Jamf or Intune, plus API integrationsDe-identify and re-identify calls in your codeA base-URL change in your model client
    Ongoing upkeepPolicy tuning to cut false positivesVault schemas, policies, and rolesEntity settings and grants
    Next stepNightfall protects data in motion through people; Skyflow protects data at rest and in use.

    Where the DLP Model Helps: You see sensitive data wherever people and tools copy it, including systems you never integrated, and G2 reviewers say Nightfall runs without constant tuning once policies settle.

    Where It Costs You: Once a value is redacted, Nightfall keeps no original. G2 reviewers also mention false positives, alert fatigue, and reporting that could go deeper.

    Where the Vault Model Helps: If every system holds a token and only the vault holds the value, a leak from a warehouse, a log, or a model prompt exposes tokens. The price is reach: Skyflow only protects systems you integrate, and it cannot see what an employee types by hand into a tool it does not sit behind.

    If your biggest exposure is a sprawling SaaS estate and heavy shadow AI use, the DLP model shows results faster. If you are rebuilding your data architecture or launching a product that will hold regulated data, the vault model gives more lasting protection.

    LLM Prompt Workflow: Nightfall vs Skyflow vs Enigma Vault NoPII

    To make the comparison concrete, here is the same job on each platform: take a customer message that contains PII, send it to an LLM inside your product, and return the reply with the real values in place.

    StepNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    1. Receive the promptYour app holds the raw textYour app holds the raw text, or tokens if the data came from the vaultYour app sends the raw text to the proxy’s base URL
    2. Find the PIIYour code calls the Developer API scan; custom detectors availableYour code calls de-identify: 60 entity types, 40+ languagesThe proxy detects 11 entity types by default, with 25+ opt-in
    3. Protect itMasked or substituted; or encrypted with your RSA keyReplaced with vault tokens, entity counters, or entity-only tagsReplaced with tokens, including in tool-call arguments and results
    4. Call the modelYour app sends the redacted textYour app sends the de-identified textThe proxy forwards the tokenized request to the provider
    5. Restore real valuesNot possible after redaction; you decrypt if you chose encryptionYour code calls re-identify for roles policy allowsRestored in the response automatically
    Next stepRun the same five steps on Enigma Vault NoPII’s free Lite tier.

    All three keep the raw PII away from the model provider. The differences show up at step 2 and step 5.

    • Step 2: Nightfall and Skyflow both need your code to call their API around each model call. Enigma Vault NoPII sits in the request path, so detection happens without extra calls.
    • Step 5: If a model reply contains “[EMAIL_ADDRESS]” after Nightfall redaction, your app has nothing to put back. Skyflow returns the real value through a re-identify call, and Enigma Vault NoPII restores it in the response.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow Features Compared

    Compare Nightfall and Skyflow on coverage, AI protection, data types, and keys. The rows where both have an answer are few, and they cluster around applications that send data to models.

    FeatureNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    Employee AI toolsShadow AI prevention through the endpoint agentNot coveredNot covered
    SaaS apps12 API-integrated apps on FoundationIntegrations for Snowflake, Databricks, ServiceNow, HubSpot, GleanNot covered
    EndpointsAgent for macOS and Windows; 2 devices per user licenseNot coveredNot covered
    Data storageNo vaultGoverned vault for PII, PHI, and cardsToken mappings held by Enigma Vault
    Coding assistantsHooks for Cursor, Claude Code, VS Code on PremierNot coveredNot covered
    Agents and MCPMCP discovery, shadow-MCP detection, MCP gatewayData governance across agents, models, and tools over MCP, A2A, or APIsTool-call arguments and results tokenized in API traffic
    Data typesText and files in scanned channelsText, files, audio, and imagesText in LLM API calls
    Entity coverageTotal not published; custom detectors60 entity types, 40+ languages11 on by default, 25+ opt-in
    ReversibilityOne-way, or encrypt with your own RSA keyRe-identify by role and policyAutomatic restore in the response
    Training dataNot coveredAI Data Sanitization with referential integrityNot covered
    PaymentsDetects card numbersPCI DSS Level 1 vaultDetects cards; Card Vault stores them
    KeysYour RSA key for encryption modeSkyflow-managed, BYOK, or BYOKMSPer-customer AES-256 keys
    SIEM exportSplunk, Sumo Logic, and Microsoft SentinelNot described on its pagesNot described on its pages
    DeploymentSaaS plus endpoint agent and integrationsSaaS, dedicated VPC, or your AWS or GCP accountManaged; self-hosted on Enterprise
    Next stepNightfall’s agent features sit on Premier; ask each vendor which rows your package includes.

    Here is how the biggest differences play out in practice.

    Where Nightfall and Skyflow Differ in Practice

    Employee Monitoring and SaaS Coverage

    Nightfall’s endpoint agent sees what happens on a laptop: copy and paste into an AI chat, a file upload to a personal drive, a browser session in an unapproved tool. Its SaaS integrations scan content at rest and in motion inside apps such as Slack, Google Drive, Jira, and Salesforce. When it finds something, policy decides whether to block, redact, coach the user, or simply alert the security team.

    Skyflow never looks at a laptop. Its work happens earlier, when data is collected and stored. If your support tool, warehouse, and analytics stack only ever receive tokens, there is far less raw data for an employee to paste anywhere, although data typed in by hand from another source stays outside its view.

    AI Agents and MCP Servers

    Both vendors added agent features in the past year, and they face opposite directions.

    Nightfall Premier watches the developer’s machine: it scans or blocks prompts, MCP tool calls, tool responses, and shell commands in Cursor, Claude Code (IDE and CLI), and VS Code.

    It discovers local stdio MCP servers, flags shadow MCP, inventories remote HTTP and SSE servers, and offers an MCP gateway that enforces data policy on tool traffic. Its pricing page says LLM model responses are monitor-only in the hooks.

    Skyflow’s homepage now opens with the line “Agents break data security,” and positions the vault between datastores, models, and agents, governing data flowing over MCP, A2A, or APIs. Skyflow announced MCP data protection in August 2025 and launched Skyflow for Glean in August 2026.

    In our reading of Skyflow’s earlier pages for the Protecto vs Skyflow comparison, several agent use cases, such as agent memory and agentic commerce, were marketing pages without matching documentation, so ask for a demo of your exact workflow.

    Reversibility: Nightfall Redaction and Skyflow Re-Identification

    This is the row that matters most for AI features inside your own product. Nightfall’s Developer API returns findings and a redacted copy of the text: masking, or substitution with a phrase or detector name. Those are one-way. Its only reversible option encrypts each finding with your RSA public key, and its docs leave decryption to you.

    Skyflow keeps the original. De-identified text carries vault tokens, entity counters, or entity-only tags, and the re-identify call returns real values to the roles your policy allows.

    That suits workflows where a person or downstream system must eventually act on the real data, such as sending a refund to the right customer after a model drafts the reply. The cost is code: your app calls de-identify before the model and re-identify after it.

    Enigma Vault NoPII

    Enigma Vault NoPII restores real values in the response with no extra calls, and it tokenizes tool-call arguments and tool results in the same pass as prompts, so a CRM lookup never sends a customer’s details to the model provider.

    Beyond Text: Files, Audio, and Training Data

    Skyflow’s de-identification handles CSV, DOC, PPT, PDF (redaction only), audio, and images, and its AI Data Sanitization product replaces PII and business-identifying information in training data while keeping referential integrity, so the same customer stays the same pseudonym across tables. That is useful if you fine-tune models or build evaluation sets from real records.

    Nightfall scans files that pass through the channels it watches, including uploads to SaaS apps and AI tools, and every plan includes 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning with paid add-ons from 1 TB to 20 TB. Its focus is finding exposures in files, and it does not publish a training-data sanitization product.

    Enigma Vault

    Enigma Vault NoPII covers text in LLM API calls. For stored records and documents, Enigma Vault has separate products: Data Vault for structured records, File Vault for documents, and Card Vault for payment cards.

    Deployment, Data Residency, and Support

    Skyflow offers multi-tenant SaaS, Virtual Private Skyflow in a dedicated VPC, and bring-your-own-cloud in your AWS or GCP account, and it sells a data residency vault and lists regulations such as DPDP among those it helps with. If data must stay in a country, Skyflow gives you more documented options.

    Nightfall runs as SaaS with an endpoint agent deployed through Jamf or Intune and exports to SIEMs such as Splunk, Sumo Logic, and Microsoft Sentinel.

    Its security page says data is hosted in the United States and describes no on-premises edition, so ask about other regions and how long findings are kept.

    On support, Nightfall publishes a dedicated customer success manager and priority support with a one-hour SLA, and G2 reviewers say to plan time for policy tuning in the first weeks.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow Security and Compliance

    Nightfall, Skyflow, and the Enigma Vault platform all state SOC 2 Type II. Skyflow also lists ISO 27001:2022 and PCI DSS Level 1, Nightfall states ISO 27001 in its pricing FAQ (its security page lists only SOC 2), and Enigma Vault is still working toward ISO 27001.

    ControlNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    SOC 2Type 2Type IIType II (Enigma Vault platform)
    ISO 27001Stated in its pricing FAQ; not on its security pageISO 27001:2022In progress
    PCI DSSNot certified as a vault; detects card dataLevel 1Level 1 Service Provider (Card, Data, File Vault in scope)
    HIPAA“HIPAA-ready” per its pricing FAQ; no certification or BAA found“Assessed and eligible”BAA on Enterprise
    Customer-managed keysRSA key for encrypted findingsBYOK and BYOKMSPer-customer AES-256 keys
    Data residencyHosted in the United States, per its security pageSaaS, dedicated VPC, or your AWS or GCP account; data residency vaultManaged; self-hosted on Enterprise
    Next stepAsk every vendor for its current audit reports and, if you handle PHI, a signed BAA.

    Skyflow’s homepage lists the regulations it helps with (HIPAA, PCI, GDPR, DPDP, CCPA, and CPRA), and its certifications appear on its security page. Nightfall’s pricing FAQ calls it “HIPAA-ready,” and its security page says it is “used commonly for HIPAA compliance”; neither is a certification. We did not find a BAA mentioned on either vendor’s public pages, so ask directly if you handle PHI.

    Nightfall vs Skyflow Reviews

    Nightfall has 101 reviews on G2 at 4.6/5, while Skyflow has 2 at 5.0/5 across its product listings. Enigma Vault NoPII has 1 on G2.

    SourceNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    G24.6/5 from 101 reviews5.0/5 from 2 reviews5.0/5 from 1 review
    Capterra5.0/5 from 2 reviewsNo listingNo listing
    Other public proofA proof of value on your own dataReviews cover payments and healthcare vaults onlyA free tier on your own prompts
    Next stepReview figures as of 22 November 2026. Ask every vendor for a reference in your industry.

    What Nightfall Reviewers Say

    Nightfall’s G2 reviewers praise its coverage of AI tools, out-of-the-box policies, and alerts delivered in Slack, and several say it runs without constant tuning. The recurring complaints are false positives, alert fatigue, and reporting and filtering that could go deeper. Plan time for policy tuning in the first weeks.

    What Skyflow Reviewers Say

    Skyflow’s G2 reviews are positive and few. One, on the Payments Data Privacy Vault, praises how it keeps payment details confidential; one, on the Healthcare Data Privacy Vault, values its HIPAA alignment and mentions occasional slowness. Neither touches its agent or AI products, so ask for reference customers using those features.

    What Enigma Vault NoPII Reviewers Say

    Enigma Vault NoPII

    One review is not a sample. The better evidence is the free tier: one million protected tokens a month, so you can judge detection on your own prompts before you pay.

    Does Nightfall Compare Itself to Skyflow?

    No, and Skyflow does not compare itself to Nightfall either. Nightfall’s comparison and alternatives pages target DLP vendors such as Microsoft Purview, Netskope, and Cyberhaven, plus a Lakera alternatives guide published in early November 2026. Skyflow’s comparison pages target Protegrity, Shift4, and Very Good Security.

    That silence is informative. Each vendor sees its real competitors in its own category, DLP for Nightfall and tokenization vaults for Skyflow, which supports the main point of this guide: they are rarely substitutes.

    If a salesperson from either side tells you the other is unnecessary, ask them to show how they would handle the steps in the LLM prompt workflow above that their product leaves to your code. For each vendor’s view of its own rivals, see our Nightfall vs Lakera and Skyflow vs VGS comparisons.

    Who Should Choose Nightfall, Skyflow, or Enigma Vault NoPII

    CISOs Facing Shadow AI Across Thousands of Employees

    Nightfall fits. The endpoint agent and SaaS integrations show what is leaving through ChatGPT, Slack, and Drive, and coaching changes behavior without banning tools. Skyflow would not see these events at all. Start with Foundation, and add Premier if engineers use Cursor or Claude Code.

    If You Govern AI Agents on a Platform Engineering Team

    If the question is which MCP servers your developers run locally and what passes through them, Nightfall Premier’s discovery and hooks are built for it. If the question is which customer records your production agents can read, Skyflow’s vault is the control point. Many teams need both, one for developer machines and one for production agent data.

    Health and Payments Companies Storing Regulated Records

    Skyflow fits the storage side, with a PCI DSS Level 1 vault and de-identification across files and audio for PHI going to AI. Add Nightfall if leakage through clinicians, agents, or SaaS tools is the main audit finding. If you want published prices for card storage, Enigma Vault’s Card Vault is also PCI DSS Level 1.

    For Product Teams That Want Published Prices and a Free Start

    If your customers’ data goes into your product’s prompts, you need protection in the request path with values restored in the reply. Nightfall’s redaction is one-way, and Skyflow needs code around each call and an enterprise contract.

    Enigma Vault NoPII does this job with a base-URL change, automatic restore, and a free Lite tier, so you can prove it on real traffic before procurement starts. Paid plans start at $49 a month.

    Questions to Ask Nightfall and Skyflow Before You Sign

    Bring these to both vendors. The answers shown are what each publishes today, so you can see where a sales call is needed.

    QuestionNightfall AISkyflowAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    What will year one cost?Per user per year, plus endpoints and data add-ons; ask for a quote at your real countsUnique Identifiers, annually in advance; ask how duplicates are countedPublished: $0, $49, $249, or $499 a month
    Can we test with real data?Through a proof of valueNot on the Try AccountYes, on Lite
    Can we get the original value back?Only through your own RSA encryptionYes, by role and policyYes, restored in the response
    Can you sign a BAA?Ask; not found on its pagesAsk; HIPAA is “assessed and eligible”On Enterprise
    Which agent features are generally available?Ask for a Premier demo on your IDEsAsk for docs behind each agent use casePublished on the product page
    How do we leave?Ask for the export process in writingAsk for the export process in writingAsk for the export process in writing
    Next stepPut the same questions to Enigma Vault.

    The last row matters most for Skyflow, because vault tokens do not transfer to another vault on their own. Agree the exit process before you sign; most buyers only ask when they are already leaving.

    Moving From Nightfall or Skyflow to Enigma Vault NoPII

    Workforce DLP and vault storage are separate jobs that do not need to move. What can move is the code that protects your own application’s model calls.

    • Find Your Scan or De-Identify Calls: List each place your app calls Nightfall’s scan API or Skyflow’s de-identification around a model call.
    • Route One Provider First: Point one model client at the Enigma Vault NoPII base URL and compare what reaches the provider.
    • Check Restored Replies: Confirm real values come back in responses where your workflow needs them.
    • Remove the Extra Calls: Once results match, drop the per-call code on that path.

    Our guide to LLM privacy proxies explains the request-path model in more detail. If you want help mapping your model calls, book a migration call.

    Final Verdict: Nightfall, Skyflow, or Enigma Vault NoPII?

    Both Nightfall and Skyflow are serious platforms.

    Nightfall is the stronger fit when the risk is sensitive data leaking through people, SaaS tools, and developers’ AI assistants. Skyflow is the stronger fit when you need a governed vault for PII, PHI, and payments that also controls what models and agents can see.

    We would decide which half of the problem you are funding first, since the two rarely replace each other, and many large companies end up running both.

    If what you need is PII kept out of one product’s LLM calls, Enigma Vault NoPII does it with a base-URL change and real values restored in every response, at published prices with a free tier. It does not monitor employees, scan SaaS apps, or store files, so if those are your main risks, it is not the right choice.

    See what reaches your model provider.

    Book a demo to map your AI data path, or explore Enigma Vault NoPII first.

    Book a demo

    More comparisons: Nightfall vs Protecto, Enigma Vault NoPII vs Nightfall, Enigma Vault NoPII vs Skyflow, and Basis Theory vs Skyflow.

    How We Researched This Comparison

    We checked vendor facts on 22 November 2026. Nightfall facts come from nightfall.ai, including its pricing page, security page, and help center. Skyflow facts come from skyflow.com, including its documentation, security page, and Terms of Service updated 15 July 2026. G2 and Capterra figures were read live on 22 November 2026, and Enigma Vault NoPII facts come from our own product and pricing pages.

    Enigma Vault publishes this page, so read it as a vendor-written comparison. Where a vendor makes a claim about itself, we label it. If something here is out of date, tell us through our contact page and we will check it.

    AK
    Abhilash Kumar Chief Growth Officer

    Abhilash Kumar is Chief Growth Officer at Enigma Vault, where he leads growth strategy, market positioning, and partnership development. He brings experience across B2B SaaS marketing, product marketing, brand building, and demand generation, with a career spanning technology companies and communications agencies.

    View full profile

    Frequently asked questions

    Is Nightfall or Skyflow Cheaper?
    Neither publishes a price, so you can only compare quotes. Nightfall sells Foundation and Premier editions priced per user per year, with two endpoint devices per license and data add-ons by volume. Skyflow bases fees on Unique Identifiers, invoiced annually in advance with a 5% increase at renewal. Which is cheaper depends on your headcount against the number of customers whose data you store. Enigma Vault NoPII starts free and costs $49, $249, or $499 a month at published volumes.
    What Is the Main Difference Between Nightfall and Skyflow?
    Nightfall is an AI-native data loss prevention platform: it scans SaaS apps, browsers, endpoints, and AI tools, and then blocks, redacts, coaches, or alerts. Skyflow is a data privacy vault: it stores sensitive values, hands your systems tokens, and re-identifies data only for roles its policies allow.
    Which Is Better for a Startup, Nightfall or Skyflow?
    Neither has a self-serve paid plan. Nightfall offers a proof of value, and Skyflow offers a free Try Account for test data only. A startup that needs to keep PII out of its own product’s LLM calls should also price Enigma Vault NoPII, whose Lite tier is free for one million protected tokens a month and whose paid tiers start at $49 a month.
    Which Has Better Reviews, Nightfall or Skyflow?
    Nightfall has far more public reviews: 4.6/5 from 101 on G2, as of 22 November 2026. Skyflow has 5.0/5 from 2 G2 reviews across its product listings, both about its payments and healthcare vaults. With so little third-party data on Skyflow’s AI products, ask both vendors for references in your industry.
    Do Nightfall and Skyflow Both Secure AI Agents and MCP Servers?
    Yes, from opposite sides. Nightfall Premier scans prompts, MCP tool calls, tool responses, and shell commands in Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code, and discovers local and remote MCP servers. Skyflow governs the sensitive data that agents, models, and tools reach over MCP, A2A, or APIs, so agents work on tokens.
    Are Nightfall and Skyflow Both SOC 2 and ISO 27001 Certified?
    Both state SOC 2 Type II. Skyflow lists ISO 27001:2022 and PCI DSS Level 1, and describes HIPAA as assessed and eligible. Nightfall’s pricing FAQ states SOC 2 Type II and ISO 27001 and calls it HIPAA-ready, while its security page lists SOC 2 Type 2 only, as of 22 November 2026. Ask both for current reports under NDA.
    Can Nightfall or Skyflow Protect Files and Audio as Well as Text?
    Yes, with limits. Skyflow’s de-identification handles CSV, DOC, PPT, PDF (redaction only), audio, and images. Nightfall scans files passing through the channels it watches, with 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning included and add-ons up to 20 TB. Enigma Vault NoPII covers text in LLM API calls only.
    What Is a Lower-Cost Alternative to Nightfall and Skyflow?
    Enigma Vault NoPII is a proxy in front of your app’s LLM API calls. It tokenizes PII before it reaches the model provider and restores real values in the response, with a free tier and published plans of $49, $249, and $499 a month. It does not monitor employees, scan SaaS apps, or store files.