NoPII

Top 10 Nightfall Alternatives and Competitors in 2026

The best Nightfall alternatives for 2026, ranked and scored on pricing transparency, AI data protection, and channel coverage.

AK Abhilash Kumar Nov 22, 2026 20 min read
On this page

    Enigma Vault

    Secure your cards.
    Protect your data.
    Keep it out of your AI.

    Data tokenization that keeps your applications working, so a breach exposes nothing worth stealing.

    • Free Lite tier, no contract
    • PCI DSS Level 1, SOC 2 Type II
    • Billed through AWS Marketplace
    Request a demo

    The best Nightfall alternatives for 2026: 1. Enigma Vault NoPII, 2. Microsoft Purview DLP, 3. Netskope One DLP, 4. Cyberhaven, 5. Forcepoint DLP, 6. Proofpoint Enterprise DLP, 7. Mimecast Incydr, 8. Zscaler DLP, 9. DTEX, 10. Cisco Cloudlock.

    Nightfall is an AI-native data loss prevention platform for SaaS apps, endpoints, browsers and email, with AI agent and MCP controls on top and Developer APIs for scanning data from your own code. Nightfall itself publishes head-to-head pages against all nine competitors below (source), and Gartner Peer Insights lists five of them as Nightfall alternatives (source).

    If what you need to protect is the customer data your own application sends to an LLM, the best alternative is Enigma Vault NoPII, which publishes every plan and starts free. If you need company-wide DLP for employees and SaaS apps, these are the strongest options:

    • Microsoft Purview DLP: Best for organizations standardized on Microsoft 365 (G2 rating 4.6 from 23 reviews)
    • Netskope One DLP: Best for teams that want DLP inside a SASE platform (G2 rating 4.4 from 98 reviews, platform-wide)
    • Cyberhaven: Best for tracing data lineage across endpoints and AI tools (G2 rating 4.5 from 19 reviews)
    • Forcepoint DLP: Best for regulated teams that need deep policy templates (G2 rating 4.3 from 45 reviews)

    Every rating in this guide links to the product’s G2 or Capterra page, and every review quote links to the review itself.

    Top 10 Alternatives to Nightfall at a Glance

    ProviderBest forHow it protects dataDeploymentStarting priceG2 ratingOur score (/5)
    Enigma Vault NoPIIKeeping PII Out of Your Own LLM API CallsTokenizes PII in LLM API traffic, restores itHosted proxy; self-hosted on EnterpriseFree, then $49/mo5.0/5 (1)3.8
    Microsoft Purview DLPOrganizations Standardized on Microsoft 365Policy DLP across Microsoft 365 and devicesMicrosoft 365 and endpointsMicrosoft licensing4.6/5 (23)3.6
    Netskope One DLPTeams That Want DLP Inside a SASE PlatformInline DLP in a SASE platformNetskope cloud and endpointContact sales4.4/5 (98)3.4
    CyberhavenTracing Data Lineage Across Endpoints and AI ToolsLineage-based DLP and insider riskEndpoint agentContact sales4.5/5 (19)3.4
    Forcepoint DLPRegulated Teams That Need Deep Policy TemplatesTemplate-driven multi-channel DLPCloud, web, email, endpointRequest pricing4.3/5 (45)3.2
    Proofpoint Enterprise DLPOrganizations Where Email Is the Main Leak PathEmail-centric DLP with insider riskEmail, cloud, endpointContact sales4.3/5 (61)3.1
    Mimecast IncydrInsider Risk Detection Across Endpoint, Browser and EmailBehavioral exfiltration detectionEndpoint agent, cloud, emailContact sales4.2/5 (72)3.1
    Zscaler DLPZscaler Customers Extending Inline ProtectionInline DLP with EDM and OCRZscaler cloud and endpointContact salesNo reviews yet2.9
    DTEXInsider Risk Programs Built on Behavioral IntelligenceBehavioral insider risk scoringEndpoint telemetry and cloudContact salesNo reviews yet2.7
    Cisco CloudlockAPI-Based CASB and DLP for Cloud AppsAPI-based CASB and DLPCloud-native, API-basedCisco salesNo reviews yet2.6

    Protect the prompts your product sends. Enigma Vault NoPII tokenizes PII before it reaches the model provider and restores it in the response. Your first million protected tokens each month are free.

    TL;DR

    • Enigma Vault NoPII (3.8/5): Replaces Nightfall’s Developer API job for your own LLM calls; free tier, then $49 a month.
    • Microsoft Purview DLP (3.6/5): The consolidation choice for Microsoft 365 shops, with Windows and macOS endpoint coverage.
    • Netskope One DLP (3.4/5): Inline DLP and GenAI guardrails for teams already routing traffic through Netskope.
    • Cyberhaven (3.4/5): Lineage-based DLP that shows where data came from before it left.
    • Forcepoint DLP (3.2/5): Template-heavy DLP for regulated teams, at the cost of more tuning.
    • Proofpoint Enterprise DLP (3.1/5): Email-first DLP with insider risk, best if you already use Proofpoint.
    • Mimecast Incydr (3.1/5): Insider risk and source code exfiltration detection with forensic detail.
    • Zscaler DLP (2.9/5): Inline DLP with Exact Data Match and OCR for existing Zscaler customers.
    • DTEX (2.7/5): Behavior-first insider risk scoring across users, data and AI activity.
    • Cisco Cloudlock (2.6/5): API-based CASB and DLP for cloud apps, closest to Nightfall’s SaaS model.

    Why Teams Look for Nightfall Alternatives

    Nightfall earns its ratings: A G2 reviewer praises its AI coverage and strong out-of-the-box policies, and it rates 4.6 on G2 from 101 reviews. The reasons buyers still evaluate alternatives are about price visibility, scope and investigation workflow.

    • The price comes after a sales call: Nightfall prices its Foundation and Premier editions per user, per year, and the amounts are not on the pricing page. Final pricing depends on user count and data volume (source).
    • There is no self-serve trial: Nightfall offers a free 7-day proof of value instead (source), so you cannot test it on your own data without a scoped engagement.
    • The platform may be bigger than the job: Foundation covers all supported SaaS apps, an endpoint agent for two devices per user and 150 GB of data-at-rest discovery, and Premier adds hooks for Cursor, Claude Code and VS Code, MCP discovery and an MCP gateway (source). A team that only needs to scrub its own application’s prompts pays for a lot it will not use.
    • Reviewers want better triage: A G2 reviewer says reporting and filters need much more improvement for analyzing events, and asks for a better analyst triage experience (source).

    If those points match your evaluation, the alternatives below sort by which part of Nightfall they replace.

    First, Decide Which Nightfall Job You Are Replacing

    Nightfall does two different jobs, and most teams only need to replace one. Picking the wrong category is the most common mistake in this search.

    If the risk is…You needStart with
    Employees sharing data in SaaS apps, email or on laptopsCompany-wide DLPPurview, Cisco Cloudlock, Netskope, Forcepoint or Proofpoint
    Insiders moving files, code or customer data off devicesEndpoint DLP and insider riskCyberhaven, Mimecast Incydr or DTEX
    Traffic you already inspect inlineDLP inside your security service edgeNetskope or Zscaler
    Your own application sending customer data to an LLM APIAn LLM privacy proxyEnigma Vault NoPII

    Some companies need both: A DLP platform for employees and a proxy for the AI features they build. The two do not overlap, because a proxy only sees traffic your application routes through it.

    How We Scored These Nightfall Alternatives

    We scored every provider on the same six criteria, weighted for a team replacing some or all of Nightfall. Weights sum to 100%, and the score in the table is the weighted result.

    • Pricing transparency and time to start (25%): Whether you can see a price and test on your own data without a sales cycle.
    • AI data protection (25%): Coverage of prompts, uploads, model responses, agents and MCP.
    • Channel coverage (15%): SaaS apps, endpoints, email and browsers.
    • Deployment effort (15%): How much you install and tune before data is protected.
    • Detection and remediation (10%): Classification quality, blocking, redaction and investigation depth.
    • Review evidence (10%): Rating and number of verified reviews on G2 and Capterra.

    Weight channel coverage higher and Netskope, Forcepoint and Purview lead; weight pricing transparency higher and Enigma Vault NoPII stays on top.

    The 10 Best Nightfall Competitors and DLP Alternatives

    Each entry covers what the product is, which part of Nightfall it replaces, what it costs, where it falls short, and what verified reviewers say.

    01

    1. Enigma Vault NoPII: Best for Keeping PII Out of Your Own LLM API Calls

    Starting price
    Free, then $49 a month
    Free tier or trial
    Lite: 1M protected tokens a month, no card
    Deployment
    Hosted proxy; self-hosted edition on Enterprise
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    The Developer API job: Scanning what your own application sends to model providers, with real values restored in the response

    Enigma Vault NoPII is an LLM privacy proxy. Your application points its model client at the NoPII base URL; NoPII swaps names, emails, account numbers and secrets for deterministic tokens before the request reaches OpenAI, Anthropic or another provider, then restores the real values in the response.

    For a Nightfall buyer, NoPII replaces one specific part of the platform: The Developer APIs (formerly Firewall for AI) that teams call to scrub prompts (source). It does not replace Nightfall’s SaaS, endpoint or email coverage, and our own NoPII page says so plainly: If the problem is employees pasting data into chatbots across hundreds of SaaS apps, you need endpoint data loss prevention.

    Key features

    • Base-URL integration: Point your model client at NoPII; no scan calls to add around each request
    • Deterministic tokens: The same customer becomes the same token in every turn and document, so the model keeps context
    • Round trip: Real values are restored before your user sees the answer
    • Agent and RAG coverage: System prompts, tool-call arguments and results, and the embeddings endpoint
    • Detection: 11 entity types on by default, 25+ to opt into, and 14 pattern families of credentials and API keys
    • Fail-closed: If tokenization fails at any step, the request is blocked and never forwarded

    Pricing

    PlanPriceProtected tokens a monthBeyond the allowance
    Lite$01M (hard cap)Upgrade prompt
    Starter$49/mo50M$1.00 per million
    Growth$249/mo500M$0.80 per million
    Business$499/mo2B$0.60 per million
    EnterpriseCustomCustom commitNegotiated or waived; includes the self-hosted edition

    Yearly billing saves on Starter, Growth and Business, and a BAA is available on NoPII Enterprise (pricing page).

    Pros

    • You can price the whole year before talking to anyone: Every tier is on the pricing page, and the free tier does not expire.
    • Answers stay readable, because real values come back in the response instead of placeholders.
    • A detection failure blocks the request, so nothing leaks on a best-effort basis.

    Cons

    • It only sees traffic your application routes through it, so Slack, Google Drive, email and laptops stay out of scope.
    • It scans text only; images, audio and files need their text extracted first.
    • Names and places are detected in English and Hindi; pattern-based identifiers work in most languages.

    What users say

    • Reviews: One G2 review so far: NoPII has a single 5/5 review on G2, written by a member of the Enigma Vault marketing team, so we do not quote it. The wider Enigma Vault listing has 6 reviews on G2.

    Rated 5.0/5 on G2 from 1 review. No Capterra listing.

    Watch for: Count where your Nightfall alerts come from. If most are SaaS or endpoint events, NoPII covers a small part of the problem.

    See it on a real message in the NoPII live demo, or read our Enigma Vault NoPII vs Nightfall comparison.

    See what reaches your model provider. Send a message with a name, email or SSN in the NoPII live demo and compare what your backend, the model provider and NoPII each receive.

    02

    2. Microsoft Purview DLP: Best for Organizations Standardized on Microsoft 365

    Starting price
    Through Microsoft 365 licensing
    Free tier or trial
    Free trial from the Purview page
    Deployment
    Microsoft 365, Windows and macOS devices, file shares
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    SaaS and endpoint DLP where most sensitive data already lives in Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams

    Microsoft Purview DLP applies data loss prevention policies to Microsoft 365 locations such as Exchange and SharePoint, and to locations you add: On-premises file shares, endpoint devices and non-Microsoft cloud apps. Nightfall publishes its own head-to-head page against it (source), and Gartner lists it among Nightfall’s alternatives (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer in a Microsoft shop, the case is consolidation: The policy engine sits inside licenses you may already own, so the question becomes whether it reaches the non-Microsoft apps and AI tools Nightfall covers today.

    Key features

    • Microsoft 365 coverage: Policies for Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive and Teams, managed from one Purview portal
    • Endpoint DLP: Protects Windows 10, Windows 11 and the three most recent macOS versions
    • Extended locations: On-premises file shares and non-Microsoft cloud apps can be added to the same policies
    • Sensitive information types: Built-in types for common identifiers, plus custom types you define
    • AI coverage: Microsoft says policies span cloud apps, email, devices and AI in one place

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Purview DLPThrough Microsoft 365 licensingNo standalone DLP price on the product page
    TrialFree trialOffered on the Purview product page
    Enterprise agreementContact SalesFor volume licensing

    Pros

    • If you already pay for the right Microsoft 365 tier, the incremental cost can be low compared with a separate per-user DLP contract.
    • Reviewers like how easy it is to create custom sensitive information types.
    • One portal covers email, files and Windows and macOS devices.

    Cons

    • Reviewers say a production rollout needs proper planning, and rules cannot be bulk-edited through PowerShell.
    • Activity exports cap at 10,000 items at a time, per one reviewer, which slows investigations at scale.
    • Licensing is harder to compare line by line with Nightfall’s per-user quote.

    What users say

    • Likes: Flexible detection: A reviewer finds it easy to create custom sensitive information types (source), and another says it detects many types of private data across locations (source).
    • Dislikes: Rollout effort and limits: Reviewers report it is tough to take into production without planning (source), that rules cannot be bulk-updated through PowerShell (source), and that activity export caps at 10,000 items (source).

    Rated 4.6/5 on G2 from 23 reviews. Capterra lists Microsoft Purview Data Loss Prevention with no reviews.

    Watch for: List the non-Microsoft SaaS apps and AI tools Nightfall monitors today, and confirm each one is reachable from Purview before you retire Nightfall.

    03

    3. Netskope One DLP: Best for Teams That Want DLP Inside a SASE Platform

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Netskope One cloud platform, inline and endpoint
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    Inline DLP for web, SaaS, endpoints and GenAI, enforced in the same platform as web and cloud access

    Netskope One DLP is the data loss prevention service inside Netskope’s security platform. It classifies PII, card numbers, financial data and intellectual property automatically and applies guardrails across cloud, web, endpoint and AI environments. Nightfall compares itself against it directly (source), and Gartner lists it among Nightfall’s alternatives (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, Netskope is the architectural opposite: Enforcement happens inline as traffic passes through the platform, rather than through API connections to each SaaS app.

    Key features

    • Automated discovery: Finds PII, payment card numbers, financial information and intellectual property on-premises and in the cloud
    • GenAI guardrails: Stops employees pasting sensitive code or data into AI models while still letting them use the tools
    • Behavior analytics: AI-driven UEBA tightens enforcement when a user’s actions look risky, such as bulk downloads before leaving
    • DSPM and DLP together: Posture management and DLP in a single architecture
    • Platform coverage: Cloud, endpoint and AI environments from the Netskope One platform

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Netskope One DLPQuoteSold as part of the Netskope One platform

    Pros

    • If you already route traffic through Netskope, DLP becomes a policy decision rather than a new deployment.
    • Behavior-aware enforcement adds context that content scanning alone misses.
    • Reviewers value having CASB, secure web gateway and DLP in one place.

    Cons

    • Reviewers describe the initial setup and policy configuration as complex, which is a big change from an API-first tool.
    • G2 does not rate Netskope One DLP on its own; the 98 reviews cover the whole platform.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Likes: One platform for many controls: A reviewer values bringing CASB, secure web gateway and other controls together (source), and another points to its deep inline visibility (source).
    • Dislikes: Complex setup: Reviewers call setup and policy configuration complex (source), and one wants simpler troubleshooting and more customizable reports (source).

    G2 rates the Netskope One Platform 4.4/5 from 98 reviews; there is no separate DLP listing. Capterra rates the Netskope One Platform 4.0 from 656 reviews.

    Watch for: If you only need DLP, a full security service edge rollout is a much larger change than swapping one API-based tool for another.

    04

    4. Cyberhaven: Best for Tracing Data Lineage Across Endpoints and AI Tools

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Endpoint coverage on Windows, Mac, Linux and VDI
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    Endpoint exfiltration prevention and insider risk, with the history of where each piece of data came from

    Cyberhaven describes itself as an AI-native data security platform that modernizes DLP, DSPM and insider risk management for people and agents. Its core idea is data lineage: It traces content from its origin through every paste, copy and rewrite, so protection follows the data rather than the file. Nightfall publishes a head-to-head page against it (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, Cyberhaven makes sense when the worry is data leaving through laptops, USB drives and AI tools, and you want to see how it got there before deciding whether it was a leak.

    Key features

    • Data lineage: Traces content from its origin through every paste, copy and rewrite by people and agents
    • Shadow AI control: Finds unsanctioned AI tools, stops sensitive data reaching prompts, uploads and agents, and reports on AI usage
    • Coding agent governance: Controls agents such as Claude Code and Cursor
    • Exfiltration blocking: USB, printer, email, personal cloud and uploads to unsanctioned web, SaaS and AI apps
    • Endpoint coverage: Windows, Mac, Linux and VDI
    • Insider risk and DSPM: Discovers and classifies exposed data across cloud, endpoint and workflows

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Cyberhaven platformQuoteDemo request on the website

    Pros

    • Lineage tells an analyst whether a file started as customer data, which content-only scanning cannot.
    • Covers Windows, Mac, Linux and VDI from one agent family.
    • A reviewer notes that user-based risk scoring is included without an extra subscription.

    Cons

    • One reviewer finds Linux coverage behind Windows and Mac, with some policies not applying.
    • Another says setup takes time to integrate fully, so plan for a longer rollout than Nightfall’s.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Likes: Real-time tracking and clear policies: A reviewer singles out real-time data tracking and mapping (source), and another likes seeing every policy laid out graphically (source).
    • Dislikes: Linux parity and setup time: One reviewer finds Linux coverage behind Windows and Mac (source), and another says setup could be simpler (source).

    Rated 4.5/5 on G2 from 19 reviews. No Capterra listing.

    Watch for: It is an endpoint-led platform, so map your device fleet and operating systems before the trial.

    05

    5. Forcepoint DLP: Best for Regulated Teams That Need Deep Policy Templates

    Starting price
    Request pricing
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Cloud, web, email and endpoint channels
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    Policy-driven DLP across email, web, cloud and endpoints, with templates for industry and regional rules

    Forcepoint DLP unifies data security for AI, cloud, web, email and endpoint with real-time enforcement and pre-defined compliance templates. Nightfall compares itself against it directly (source), and Gartner lists it among Nightfall’s alternatives (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, Forcepoint trades setup speed for depth: More policy detail and channel coverage, with more tuning work up front.

    Key features

    • Multi-channel enforcement: One policy set for AI, cloud, web, email and endpoint
    • Compliance templates: Pre-defined templates for industry and regional rules such as GDPR and CCPA
    • ARIA assistant: An AI assistant that surfaces insights, recommends protection and deploys policies from a chat interface
    • AI Mesh classification: Discovers and classifies structured and unstructured data across data stores
    • Risk-adaptive policies: Adjusts enforcement automatically as a user’s behavior changes
    • Cloud DLP: Extends protection for Google Workspace and Microsoft 365

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Forcepoint DLPRequest PricingStart Today route on the product page

    Pros

    • Pre-built templates shorten the work of mapping policies to specific regulations.
    • Reviewers praise centralized visibility across endpoints, email, web and cloud.
    • Rated 4.5 on Capterra from 17 reviews, alongside 4.3 on G2.

    Cons

    • Reviewers consistently describe initial setup and policy configuration as complex.
    • Some alerts need extra tuning before they are useful, according to a reviewer.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Likes: Centralized visibility: Reviewers value centralized visibility across endpoints, email, web and cloud (source) and strong control across channels (source).
    • Dislikes: Complex setup and tuning: Reviewers report complex initial setup and policy configuration (source) and alerts that need extra tuning (source).

    Rated 4.3/5 on G2 from 45 reviews and 4.5/5 on Capterra from 17 reviews.

    Watch for: Budget analyst time for policy tuning in the first months; every reviewer we read mentions it.

    06

    6. Proofpoint Enterprise DLP: Best for Organizations Where Email Is the Main Leak Path

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Email, cloud, endpoint and web channels
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    DLP and insider risk analysis, built around email and extended to cloud, endpoint and GenAI

    Proofpoint Enterprise DLP positions itself as data loss prevention for people, data and AI. It applies one set of policies and classifiers across channels and pairs DLP with insider risk analysis. Nightfall publishes a head-to-head page against it (source), and Gartner lists it first among Nightfall’s alternatives (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer that already uses Proofpoint for email security, this is the consolidation option.

    Key features

    • GenAI controls: Detects and controls sensitive data in prompts and uploads, including unsanctioned AI tools
    • Unified policies: Applies the same policies and data classifiers across channels from one platform
    • Insider risk analysis: Analyzes activity and data flows to identify exfiltration and insider risk
    • Threat intelligence: Uses AI and threat intel to assess data risk
    • Email DLP: Built on Proofpoint’s email security, alongside cloud and endpoint

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Enterprise DLPQuoteDemo request and How to Buy

    Pros

    • One vendor for email security and DLP removes an integration.
    • Reviewers say it prevents incidents well once policies are crafted correctly.
    • Alerts show who did what, which reviewers find helpful for triage.

    Cons

    • A reviewer reports many false positives on the PCI rule, including matches in file metadata.
    • Another says the API documentation needs a lot of work, which matters if developers will call it.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Likes: Effective once tuned: A reviewer says it prevents DLP incidents well once policies are crafted correctly (source), and another likes how alerts show who and what each one is about (source).
    • Dislikes: False positives and API docs: One reviewer gets many false positives around the PCI rule (source), and another says the API documentation needs a lot of work (source).

    Rated 4.3/5 on G2 from 61 reviews. Capterra lists it with no reviews.

    Watch for: Run your own PCI sample through it during the trial; that is where reviewers report the most noise.

    07

    7. Mimecast Incydr: Best for Insider Risk Detection Across Endpoint, Browser and Email

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Lightweight endpoint agent for Mac, Windows and Linux, plus cloud and email
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    Exfiltration detection and investigation across endpoint, browser, cloud sync, email and AI tools

    Mimecast Incydr began as Code42 Incydr; code42.com now redirects to Mimecast’s data protection page. It uses behavioral, context-driven detection to catch exfiltration across endpoints, cloud, email and AI tools, and records each file movement with who moved it and where it went. Nightfall compares itself against it under the Code42 name (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, Incydr suits a security team that cares most about departing employees and source code leaving, and wants forensic detail for each event.

    Key features

    • Endpoint agent: A lightweight agent for Mac, Windows and Linux
    • Exfiltration detection: USB, browser, cloud sync, AirDrop, Git and GenAI destinations
    • Source code protection: Records the file, repository, destination and user when code goes to personal or untrusted destinations
    • Watchlists: Monitors departing and high-risk users, with dashboards and alerting
    • Investigation: Forensic search, case management and Instructor coaching for users
    • Integrations: 350+ integrations, plus API and MCP connections

    Pricing

    PackagePriceWhat it includes
    Data Protection for emailQuoteOutbound email inspection, admin hold, forensic search and an Investigation Agent with 50 AI credits a month; requires Mimecast Apex Email and Collaboration Security
    Package with endpointQuoteAdds exfiltration detection on every endpoint

    Pros

    • Reviewers say it gives useful visibility quickly, with a lot of context in one interface.
    • The lightweight agent covers Windows, Mac and Linux.
    • Source code and Git destinations are first-class detection channels.

    Cons

    • A reviewer says it is stronger on detection than prevention.
    • Another notes preventative controls block by destination or application, with content-aware blocking less granular.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Likes: Fast, useful visibility: A reviewer likes how quickly it provides genuinely useful visibility (source), and another values how much information it brings together without cluttering the interface (source).
    • Dislikes: Detection over prevention: One reviewer finds it stronger on detection than prevention (source), and another wants more granular content-aware blocking (source).

    Rated 4.2/5 on G2 from 72 reviews. No Capterra listing.

    Watch for: If blocking in the moment matters more than investigation, test its preventative controls on your top exfiltration paths.

    08

    8. Zscaler DLP: Best for Zscaler Customers Extending Inline Protection

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Zscaler cloud inline, with a lightweight endpoint agent
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    DLP inspection for web, email and endpoints inside the Zscaler zero trust platform

    Zscaler DLP delivers DLP inspection across web and email traffic and extends it to endpoints with a lightweight agent. Its classification includes Exact Data Match, Indexed Document Matching and OCR for images. Nightfall publishes a head-to-head page against it (source), and Gartner lists Zscaler among Nightfall’s alternatives (source).

    It makes most sense for a Nightfall buyer whose traffic already flows through Zscaler, where DLP is an extension of an existing platform.

    Key features

    • Unified DLP: One policy across web, endpoint and email
    • Exact Data Match: Fingerprints specific records, such as customer data, to cut false positives
    • Indexed Document Matching and OCR: Classifies documents and text inside images, including images embedded in Word files
    • Endpoint DLP: A lightweight agent with process-level context
    • GenAI protection: Supports safe GenAI workflows, per Zscaler’s data protection page

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    Zscaler DLPQuoteRequest a demo or contact sales

    Pros

    • Exact Data Match lets you fingerprint your own customer records instead of relying on patterns alone.
    • OCR covers sensitive data inside images and embedded screenshots.
    • No new traffic path if you already run Zscaler.

    Cons

    • Zscaler DLP has no G2 reviews yet, so there is little independent feedback.
    • Outside an existing Zscaler deployment, it is a platform purchase rather than a point tool.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Reviews: No reviews yet: Zscaler DLP has no G2 reviews yet, so ask for reference customers.

    No G2 reviews yet for Zscaler DLP. Capterra lists Zscaler Internet Access but not Zscaler DLP.

    Watch for: Confirm how data at rest inside SaaS apps is covered, since inline inspection sees traffic in transit.

    09

    9. DTEX: Best for Insider Risk Programs Built on Behavioral Intelligence

    Starting price
    Contact sales
    Free tier or trial
    Demo
    Deployment
    Endpoint telemetry with a cloud platform
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    Insider risk detection that scores behavior across users, data and AI activity, rather than scanning content alone

    DTEX describes itself as a risk-adaptive security platform that unifies human, data and AI risk through behavioral intelligence. It collects more than 500 metadata elements and correlates activity across devices into one risk score. Nightfall publishes a head-to-head page against it (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, DTEX is the choice when the main question is intent: Whether a user is malicious, careless or compromised, before any file leaves.

    Key features

    • Behavioral risk scoring: Correlates more than 500 metadata elements across devices into one risk score
    • Behavioral domains: More than 12 human-driven domains, tuned by AI modeling to reduce noise
    • Baselines: Profiles behavior by role, department and geography, and separates human from AI activity
    • AI Risk Management: Tracks risk created by AI usage and agentic workflows
    • AI analysts: A multi-agent triage system and a Deep Researcher hunting agent
    • Services: Insider Investigations and Intelligence (i3) from DTEX’s own team

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    DTEX platformQuoteRequest a demo
    i3 servicesQuoteInsider investigations and intelligence

    Pros

    • Behavior-first detection tells malicious, careless and compromised activity apart, which content scanning cannot.
    • DTEX says it identifies outlier behavior within 10 days of deployment.
    • An in-house investigations team is available as a service.

    Cons

    • It is an insider risk platform first, so in-app SaaS remediation is not its focus the way it is for Nightfall.
    • DTEX has no reviews on G2 or Capterra, so there is no independent feedback to weigh.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Reviews: No reviews yet: DTEX inTERCEPT is listed on G2 and DTEX Systems on Capterra, both with no reviews, so ask for reference customers.

    No reviews on G2 or Capterra yet.

    Watch for: If your Nightfall use is mostly SaaS remediation, check how DTEX handles data already exposed inside cloud apps.

    10

    10. Cisco Cloudlock: Best for API-Based CASB and DLP for Cloud Apps

    No reviewsG2 and Capterra
    Starting price
    Through Cisco sales
    Free tier or trial
    Trials and demos through Cisco
    Deployment
    Cloud-native, API-based
    What it replaces from Nightfall
    API-based DLP and app control for sanctioned cloud apps, the part of Nightfall that scans SaaS data

    Cisco Cloudlock is a cloud-native cloud access security broker that uses APIs to manage risk in your cloud app ecosystem. Its DLP continuously monitors cloud environments with out-of-the-box and custom policies. Nightfall publishes a head-to-head page against it (source).

    For a Nightfall buyer, Cloudlock is the closest architectural match on SaaS: Both connect to cloud apps through APIs rather than proxying traffic.

    Key features

    • API-based CASB: Connects to cloud apps through APIs, with no proxy in front of users
    • Cloud DLP: Continuously monitors cloud environments with out-of-the-box and custom policies
    • User behavior analytics: Flags anomalies, activity outside allowed countries and impossible travel
    • Apps Firewall: Discovers apps connected to your cloud accounts, with a crowd-sourced Community Trust Rating
    • App control: Ban or allowlist connected apps based on risk

    Pricing

    OptionPriceNotes
    CloudlockThrough Cisco salesHow to Buy and Trials and Demos routes on Cisco’s site

    Pros

    • API-based like Nightfall’s SaaS coverage, so no proxy sits in front of users.
    • Apps Firewall adds control over third-party apps connected to your cloud accounts.
    • A fit for organizations already buying security from Cisco.

    Cons

    • It covers cloud apps; endpoints and AI tools on devices need other products.
    • Cloudlock has no product listing on G2 or Capterra, so independent reviews are hard to find.
    • No published pricing.

    What users say

    • Reviews: No review-site listing: Cisco Cloudlock has no product listing on G2 or Capterra, so ask Cisco for reference customers.

    No G2 or Capterra product listing.

    Watch for: Check which of your SaaS apps Cloudlock connects to, and plan separate endpoint coverage if Nightfall’s agent is in use today.

    Nightfall vs Enigma Vault NoPII

    These are different products that overlap on one job: Keeping sensitive data out of the prompts your own application sends to a model. Here is how they line up on that job.

    NightfallAlso considerEnigma Vault NoPII
    What it isDLP platform with Developer APIs for scanning and redactionLLM privacy proxy for your application’s model calls
    How you integrateCall the scan APIs from your codePoint your model client at the NoPII base URL
    What the model receivesWhat your code sends after redactionDeterministic tokens; real values restored in the response
    PricingPer user, per year, through salesFree for 1M tokens a month, then $49, $249, $499
    TrialFree 7-day proof of valueFree Lite plan that does not expire
    SaaS, endpoint and email DLPYesNo
    Next stepLive in minutes with a base-URL change.

    Nightfall covers far more surface. NoPII does one job, protecting the LLM traffic your applications generate, with a price you can read before you talk to anyone.

    How to Choose a Nightfall Alternative

    Where do your alerts come from today? Pull a month of Nightfall events by source. Mostly SaaS points to Purview, Netskope or Forcepoint; mostly endpoint points to Cyberhaven or Incydr; mostly your own AI features points to NoPII.

    What does your network already run? If traffic goes through Netskope or Zscaler, adding DLP there is a policy change. If you are Microsoft 365 end to end, Purview is the first comparison your finance team will ask for.

    Do you need to block or to investigate? Forcepoint and Netskope lean toward enforcement; Cyberhaven and Incydr lean toward context and forensics.

    How much tuning can you staff? Reviewers of almost every enterprise DLP platform here mention policy tuning. If you have one analyst, weigh that more than the feature list.

    Best Nightfall Alternative by Scenario

    ScenarioBest pickWhy
    AI features in your own productEnigma Vault NoPIITokenizes PII in prompts, tool calls and embeddings and restores it in responses
    Microsoft 365 shopMicrosoft Purview DLPPolicies inside Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive, Teams and Windows and macOS devices
    Already on a security service edgeNetskope One DLPInline DLP in the platform that already carries your traffic
    Data leaving through laptops and AI toolsCyberhavenLineage across Windows, Mac, Linux and VDI
    Strict regulatory policiesForcepoint DLPPre-defined templates for industry and regional compliance
    Email is the main leak pathProofpoint Enterprise DLPEmail-centric DLP with insider risk
    Departing employees and source codeMimecast IncydrDetection for Git, USB, AirDrop and cloud sync, with forensics
    Existing Zscaler customerZscaler DLPExact Data Match and OCR inside the platform you run
    Insider intent and behaviorDTEXBehavioral risk scoring that separates malicious, careless and compromised users
    API-based SaaS coverage on CiscoCisco CloudlockAPI-based CASB with DLP and app control

    What Moving Off Nightfall Actually Involves

    • Export your detection rules first: Nightfall policies, custom detectors and exclusions do not import into another product. Write them down while you still have access.
    • Map each integration: Nightfall connects to SaaS apps through APIs. Inline platforms such as Netskope and Zscaler see traffic differently, so check each app one by one.
    • Plan the endpoint swap: Two endpoint agents on the same device can conflict. Agree the order of removal and install with IT.
    • Re-baseline your noise: A new classifier produces a new set of false positives. Expect a tuning period before alert volumes settle.
    • Move API callers separately: If your developers call Nightfall’s scan APIs, that code path changes independently of the employee DLP rollout.

    Try Enigma Vault NoPII on Your Own Traffic

    If the part of Nightfall you are replacing is the API that scrubs your application’s prompts, you can prove NoPII on your own traffic before you talk to anyone. The free plan is a permanent tier, not a trial, and moving an existing integration onto it is a base-URL change.

    What the free Lite plan includesDetail
    Protected tokens1M a month, hard cap, no credit card
    Model providersEvery supported provider, including OpenAI, Anthropic and Google Gemini
    ProtectionPII detection and tokenization, with values restored in the response
    AuditFull audit trail with 7-day log history
    Limits1 workspace, 1 user, 25 custom terms, 60 requests a minute per key, 1-day token retention
    Upgrade pathStarter at $49 a month for 50M tokens, with no re-integration

    How to run a fair test in a week

    1. Pick one AI feature: Choose the feature that sends the most customer data to a model today, such as a support assistant or a summarizer.
    2. Point it at NoPII: Change the model client’s base URL to NoPII in a staging environment. No other code changes are needed.
    3. Send real-shaped traffic: Replay a sample of production prompts, including tool calls and any embeddings requests.
    4. Check what left your system: Compare what your backend sent with what the model provider received in the audit trail. Every name, email and account number should arrive as a token.
    5. Check the answers: Confirm your users still see real values in the responses, and that answers read as well as before.
    6. Decide with numbers: Use the token count from the trial to price the right plan before anyone signs anything.

    When NoPII is not the right fit: If most of your risk is employees sharing data in SaaS apps, email or on laptops, NoPII will not see that traffic, and one of the DLP platforms above is the better choice. Many teams run both: A DLP platform for employees, and NoPII for the AI features they build.

    See what reaches your model provider.

    Book a demo to map your AI data path, or try the live demo first. If a DLP platform on this list fits you better, we will say so.

    Book a demo

    More comparisons: Enigma Vault NoPII vs Nightfall AI, Protecto alternatives and Limina alternatives.

    AK
    Abhilash Kumar Chief Growth Officer

    Abhilash Kumar is Chief Growth Officer at Enigma Vault, where he leads growth strategy, market positioning, and partnership development. He brings experience across B2B SaaS marketing, product marketing, brand building, and demand generation, with a career spanning technology companies and communications agencies.

    View full profile

    Frequently asked questions

    Who are Nightfall’s main competitors?
    Nightfall publishes head-to-head pages against nine competitors: Forcepoint, Code42 (now Mimecast Incydr), Cyberhaven, Cisco Cloudlock, Proofpoint, DTEX, Netskope, Microsoft Purview and Zscaler. Gartner Peer Insights lists Proofpoint, Forcepoint, Microsoft Purview, Google Cloud Sensitive Data Protection, Zscaler, Netskope, Reveal and Trellix as alternatives.
    What is the best Nightfall alternative?
    For protecting the data your own application sends to an LLM, Enigma Vault NoPII scores highest at 3.8 out of 5 on our weighting. For company-wide DLP, Microsoft Purview DLP scores 3.6 and has a 4.6 G2 rating from 23 reviews.
    How much does Nightfall cost?
    Nightfall prices its Foundation and Premier editions per user, per year, and does not publish the amounts. Final pricing depends on user count and data volume.
    Does Nightfall have a free trial?
    Nightfall offers a free 7-day proof of value in place of a self-serve trial, according to its pricing page.
    What is the difference between Nightfall Foundation and Premier?
    Foundation covers all supported SaaS apps, an endpoint agent for two devices per user, AI-based classification and lineage, Nyx autonomous investigation and 150 GB of data-at-rest discovery. Premier adds hooks for Cursor, Claude Code and VS Code, MCP server discovery, MCP gateway enforcement and Claude Enterprise coverage.
    Is Code42 Incydr the same as Mimecast Incydr?
    Yes. Code42’s website now redirects to Mimecast’s data protection page, and G2 lists the product as Mimecast Incydr.
    Can Enigma Vault NoPII replace Nightfall?
    Only for one job. NoPII protects the LLM API traffic your applications route through its proxy. It does not cover SaaS apps, endpoints, email or employees pasting data into AI websites, which need a DLP platform.
    Which Nightfall alternative works best with Microsoft 365?
    Microsoft Purview DLP is built into Microsoft 365 and covers Exchange, SharePoint, OneDrive, Teams and Windows and macOS devices.
    Which Nightfall alternative is best for endpoint DLP?
    Cyberhaven covers Windows, Mac, Linux and VDI with data lineage, and Mimecast Incydr runs a lightweight agent on Mac, Windows and Linux with detection for USB, browser, cloud sync, AirDrop, Git and GenAI.
    Is there a free Nightfall alternative?
    Enigma Vault NoPII has a free Lite plan with one million protected tokens a month that does not expire. The DLP platforms on this list start with a demo or a trial.