Nightfall and Protecto both keep sensitive data away from AI models, Nightfall by watching the people, SaaS apps, and coding agents that move data out, and Protecto by masking data inside the RAG pipelines and agents your engineers build.
This guide compares Nightfall and Protecto on architecture, features, pricing, compliance, and reviews, with Enigma Vault NoPII alongside as a third option for teams that want published prices and a simpler start.
Nightfall is best for security teams that need workforce data loss prevention across AI tools, SaaS, and endpoints, while Protecto is best for AI platform teams that must use sensitive data inside the systems they build and restore it for the right users.
Nightfall vs Protecto at a Glance
| Vendor | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Workforce DLP across SaaS, browsers, endpoints, and coding agents | Masking and unmasking inside RAG pipelines and agents you build | PII in your own app’s LLM calls |
| Entry price | Editions per user by quote | Previously $250/mo for 5,000 API calls; no prices shown (22 Nov) | Free, then $49/mo |
| Free option | Free 7-day proof of value | Trial or POC through sales (as of 22 Nov) | Free Lite tier, 1M protected tokens a month |
| Architecture | Browser plugins, endpoint agent, SaaS connectors, agent hooks, Developer API | Mask and unmask API, privacy gateway for chat tools, LiteLLM adapter | Proxy: change the model client’s base URL |
| G2 | 4.6/5 (101) | Listed, 0 reviews | 5/5 (1) |
| Capterra | 5.0/5 (2) | Listed, 0 reviews | No listing |
| Next step | Free Lite tier on Enigma Vault NoPII. Published plans from $49 a month. | ||
Figures are as of 22 November 2026, from each vendor’s own site and docs and from G2 and Capterra, with every vendor fact and pricing page checked on 22 November 2026. For more options, see our guides to Nightfall alternatives and Protecto alternatives.
Nightfall vs Protecto: Quick Verdict
Nightfall AI: An AI-native data loss prevention platform. It watches prompts, uploads, and copy and paste into AI tools, scans SaaS apps such as Slack, Google Drive, and email, and on its Premier edition adds hooks that scan and block prompts, MCP tool calls, and shell commands in Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code. Editions are sold per user by quote.
Protecto: A masking and tokenization layer built for generative AI. A headless REST API replaces sensitive values with typed, context-preserving tokens and returns real values only through permissioned unmask calls. It runs as SaaS or inside your own network, including air-gapped, and published plans started at $250 a month.
Enigma Vault NoPII: A hosted privacy proxy for LLM APIs. You change your model client’s base URL, and PII is tokenized before it reaches the model provider and restored in the response. It is free for one million protected tokens a month, then $49, $249, or $499.
Pick Nightfall when:
- Your biggest exposure is employees pasting customer data into ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude, or sharing it in Slack and Drive.
- Developers use coding agents and MCP servers, and security wants to see and block what those agents send.
- You buy security tools per seat, want a 1-hour support SLA, and can run a proof of value before signing.
Pick Protecto when:
- You are building RAG search, copilots, or agents, and data must be masked at ingestion and unmasked only for the right user.
- Processing has to stay in your VPC, your data center, or an air-gapped network that you operate.
- You want a published monthly price tied to API calls, and you can wait for features its docs still label coming soon.
Pick Enigma Vault NoPII when:
- You want published prices and a free tier before any sales process.
- Your scope is the LLM API calls your own applications make, and replies must come back with real values.
- You want one client setting changed instead of mask and unmask code at each step, and you can live without workforce DLP and data-at-rest scanning.
In short: Nightfall controls what people and their tools send out, Protecto masks data inside the AI you build, and Enigma Vault NoPII covers your own app’s LLM calls at published prices. Many enterprises will need an answer to both of the first two jobs, so treat Nightfall and Protecto as neighbors before treating them as rivals.
How Nightfall and Protecto Differ at the Core
Nightfall sits at the edges where people and their tools touch data and usually stops or redacts what it finds, whereas Protecto sits inside the systems your engineers write and swaps data for tokens the model can still reason about.
To make it concrete, follow one support prompt that contains a customer’s name and card number, handled according to each vendor’s documented behavior.
| Piece of data | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Card number | Masked such as ************4242, or [CREDIT_CARD_NUMBER], or the prompt is blocked | Typed token, with format-preserving options | Consistent token, labelled as an account number |
| Customer name | Masked, substituted, or removed | Typed token that keeps context | Same token for the same person across the chat |
| Model reply | Placeholders stay unless you decrypt | Unmask call for permitted users | Real values restored automatically, including streams |
| Context kept | Low with placeholders | Protecto reports 85% semantic accuracy in a bank pilot | Consistent tokens keep relationships |
| Where it runs | Nightfall’s cloud, fed by plugins, agents, and connectors | Its cloud, your VPC, on-premises, or air-gapped | Managed; self-hosted on Enterprise |
| Next step | Nightfall’s proof of value, Protecto’s trial, and Enigma Vault NoPII’s Lite tier are all free ways to test. Enigma Vault NoPII’s first paid plan is $49 a month. | ||
Nightfall’s Model: Find sensitive data wherever people and their tools move it, then block, redact, quarantine, or coach the user. That protects the data, and the task the employee wanted done either fails or runs on a placeholder. It suits a security team whose goal is “this data should not leave.”
Protecto’s Model: Replace each value with a typed token at the point your pipeline handles it, and restore it only through a permissioned unmask call. The model still knows it is looking at a card number and can reason about it. It suits a product team whose goal is “this data must be used, without the model provider seeing it.”
Enigma Vault NoPII’s Model: Sit between your app and the model provider as a proxy. Values are tokenized on the way out and restored on the way back, with no mask or unmask calls in your code.
If your hard problem is staff and their tools sending data out, Nightfall’s model fits. If it is using sensitive data inside RAG and agent systems you build, Protecto’s model fits. If it is one app’s LLM calls that must keep real values in every reply, Enigma Vault NoPII’s model fits.
Nightfall vs Protecto Security and Compliance
Nightfall, Protecto, and Enigma Vault all state SOC 2 Type II. Protecto and Nightfall’s pricing FAQ both state ISO 27001, with no certificate we could find for either, Nightfall’s security page does not mention it, and Enigma Vault is still working toward it.
| Control | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| SOC 2 | Type 2, on its security page | Type II, stated; no report found | Type II (Enigma Vault platform) |
| ISO 27001 | Stated in its pricing FAQ; not on its security page; no certificate found | Stated; no certificate found | In progress |
| HIPAA | “HIPAA-ready”; maps to the Security Rule | BAA when Protecto hosts or can access your instance | BAA available |
| Regional laws | States “GDPR-compliant”; compliance pages for CCPA and CPRA | GDPR, DPDP, CCPA, and Gulf laws such as Saudi PDPL | GDPR erasure by token purge |
| Where data is processed | Nightfall’s cloud | Its cloud, or inside your network | Managed; self-hosted on Enterprise |
| Audit trail | SIEM export to Splunk, Panther, and Sumo (Premier) | Audit logs for mask and unmask calls | Audit log of every protected request |
| Next step | Ask every vendor for current audit reports under NDA and a signed BAA before you send PHI. | ||
Nightfall describes itself as “HIPAA-ready,” which is not a certification. The claims look similar on paper, and the real difference is where data is processed: with Protecto self-run, the data never reaches a vendor, which can simplify a vendor risk review more than any certificate.
Nightfall vs Protecto Features Compared
Compare Nightfall and Protecto on detection, masking, channels, agents, and deployment. Nightfall covers more channels, Protecto gives more control over what happens to a value once it is found, and both leave some capabilities to a sales conversation.
| Feature | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core model | DLP platform with plugins, agents, connectors, and a Developer API | Mask and unmask API, chat gateway, and LiteLLM adapter | Proxy in front of LLM APIs |
| Detection approach | AI-based detectors plus custom detectors; total count not published | 200+ entity types marketed; 53 in its docs; custom entities | 11 types on by default, 25+ opt-in, 14 credential families |
| What it does on a match | Block, redact, quarantine, notify, or coach the user | Typed token, with format-preserving and entropy-based options | Consistent token per value across a conversation |
| Restoring values | Only via its RSA encryption mode, decrypted by you | Unmask API for permitted users | Automatic in the response, including streams |
| Languages | Not published | Six in its docs; seven in marketing | Pattern types in most languages |
| Workforce channels | Browsers, endpoints (2 devices per user), SaaS, email | Not covered | Not covered |
| Coding agents and MCP | Hooks for Cursor, Claude Code, VS Code; MCP discovery and inventory (Premier) | GPTGuard MCP labelled coming soon in its docs | Tool-call arguments and results tokenized |
| Internal chat tools | Claude Enterprise, through hooks and the Compliance API | Privacy gateway for LibreChat; Open WebUI on request | Any app calling a supported LLM API |
| RAG pipelines | Developer API scan before you embed, one-way | Mask at ingestion, unmask for permitted users | Embeddings requests tokenized |
| Data at rest | 150 GB included; 1 to 20 TB annual packs as an add-on | Data Scanning API on paid plans | Not offered |
| SIEM and audit | Export to Splunk, Panther, and Sumo (Premier) | Audit logs for mask and unmask calls | Audit log of every protected request |
| Deployment | SaaS, with agents deployed through Jamf or Intune | SaaS, VPC, on-premises, air-gapped | Managed; self-hosted on Enterprise |
| Next step | Protecto’s docs label some marketed features coming soon. Ask each vendor what is generally available. | ||
Here is how the biggest differences play out in practice.
Where Nightfall and Protecto Differ in Practice
Access Control and Restoring Values
Protecto’s design centers on unmasking. Values come back only through explicit API calls, and its chat gateway maps Okta or Active Directory groups to a per-user key, so a support agent and an analyst can see different things in the same reply. Its finer context-based access control has a product page, while its docs roadmap lists it, and Dynamic Auth, as preview features not yet generally available.
Nightfall is built to keep sensitive data from reaching the wrong place, so restoring values is outside its main job. Its Developer API masks, substitutes, or removes values one-way, and its one reversible mode encrypts findings with your RSA public key. Nightfall does not hold that key, so decryption is code you write.
For a product where different users must see different values in the same answer, Protecto’s model is the more granular. For a security team that only needs data to stay home, one-way redaction is enough.
Workforce and SaaS Coverage
This is Nightfall’s home ground. Its browser plugins watch prompts, uploads, and copy and paste into public AI tools, its endpoint agent covers two devices per user license, and its SaaS connectors scan Slack, Google Drive, and email. Both editions include 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning, with annual packs of 1, 3, 5, and 20 TB sold as an add-on.
Protecto does not watch employee browsers, endpoints, or SaaS apps. Its Data Scanning API, on paid plans, covers data stores your team points it at. A company whose staff paste customer records into public AI tools would still need a product like Nightfall alongside Protecto.
AI and Agent Data
“Agents” means different things on each site. Nightfall’s Premier edition protects the agents your employees run: hooks for Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code scan and block prompts, MCP tool calls, tool responses, and shell commands, while model responses are monitor-only.
It also discovers local and remote MCP servers and flags shadow MCP use. As of 22 November 2026, its pricing page lists MCP Gateway policy enforcement in the Premier package.
Protecto protects the agents your company ships. It masks data before an agent’s model call and unmasks at the tool boundary, masks RAG documents at ingestion so tokens sit in your vector store, and offers a LiteLLM adapter. Its GPTGuard MCP product is labelled coming soon in its docs.
Enigma Vault NoPII covers a narrower job. It tokenizes prompts, system prompts, embeddings requests, tool-call arguments, and tool results in your application’s LLM API calls, with a free tier of one million protected tokens a month. It does not cover workforce DLP or coding agents on employee machines.
Deployment and Data Residency
Protecto’s self-run model uses the same API as its SaaS and runs on AWS, GCP, Azure, or your own data center, with air-gapped use listed. In that model you own scaling, monitoring, backups, and upgrades, and its trial is SaaS only.
Nightfall installs a browser plugin and an endpoint agent on your devices and deploys through Jamf or Intune, and the analysis runs in Nightfall’s cloud. We found no on-premises edition. For banks and public-sector teams with in-country rules, this one difference can decide the purchase.
Enigma Vault NoPII is managed by default, and its Enterprise plan adds a self-hosted edition.
Detection Accuracy Claims
Nightfall advertises 95% detection precision, which its Lakera alternatives guide says was measured on customer data during limited proofs of value. Protecto reports 99% recall and 96% precision from a four-week proof of concept at Bank Muscat and a third-party benchmark by UT Dallas and DataXpert, updated March 2025, that it publishes.
All of these are vendor-reported, and neither benchmark includes the other vendor. G2 reviewers of Nightfall mention false positives among their complaints, which is normal for DLP tuned to catch more rather than less.
Enigma Vault NoPII publishes the results of 109 automated tests on its engine and makes no independent accuracy claim. The fair test for all three is your own prompts and documents.
Time to First Value and Support
Protecto previously advertised a 14-day SaaS trial; as of 22 November 2026, its docs say to contact sales for POC or trial access. Nightfall has no self-serve trial; it offers a free 7-day proof of value. Its help center documents a free Developer API plan for 3 GB of scanned data a month, then custom Enterprise pricing; its main pricing page does not mention it.
On support, both Nightfall editions include a dedicated customer success manager and priority support with a 1-hour SLA. Protecto’s Enterprise plan listed 24/7 dedicated support when prices were published, and its on-premises support SLA targets a 1-hour response for critical issues; ask for its SaaS terms.
Nightfall vs Protecto Pricing
What Nightfall Charges
Nightfall’s pricing page lists two editions and no dollar figures. Foundation covers DLP for SaaS, email, AI apps, and endpoints, with data detection and response and exfiltration prevention. Premier adds coding-agent hooks, MCP discovery, MCP Gateway policy enforcement, an OpenTelemetry audit trail, Claude Compliance API coverage, and SIEM export, with Tier 1 covering up to 3 apps and Tier 2 covering all supported apps.
Both editions include 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning, with more sold in annual packs of 1, 3, 5, and 20 TB. Each user license includes 2 endpoint devices, and quotes follow a proof of value.
What Protecto Charges
An archived copy of Protecto’s SaaS page (6 October 2026) shows SaaS plans billed per API call, where one call can carry an array of values of up to 600 characters each. Starter was $250 a month for 5,000 API calls, with higher tiers at $500 a month for 12,000 calls and $750 a month for 16,000 calls. Enterprise is by quote and includes on-premises and 24/7 dedicated support.
Overage rates are not published, and async masking and Data Scanning need a paid plan. When we checked on 22 November 2026, Protecto’s SaaS page showed deployment options and a demo link with no price table, so ask sales to confirm these figures.
What Enigma Vault NoPII Charges
Every tier is published. Lite is free for one million protected tokens a month, with no card. Starter is $49 a month ($550 a year) for 50M tokens, then $1.00 per million.
Growth is $249 a month ($2,700 a year) for 500M tokens, then $0.80 per million. Business is $499 a month ($5,500 a year) for 2B tokens, then $0.60 per million. You sign up at app.nopii.co, and Enterprise adds self-hosting.
Nightfall vs Protecto Cost at Three Business Sizes
| Business size | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Startup adding one LLM feature | Foundation, per-user quote | $250/mo (5,000 calls), or $3,000 a year | $0 on Lite; $49/mo or $550 a year on Starter |
| Growing company with several AI features | Premier Tier 1 or Tier 2, plus storage packs | $500/mo (12,000) or $750/mo (16,000) | $249/mo (Growth) |
| Large or on-premises | Enterprise quote; SaaS only | Enterprise quote with on-premises | Enterprise with self-hosting |
| Next step | Nightfall publishes no prices and Protecto’s price table was still offline on 22 November, so ask both for a written quote at your volume. | ||
How to Read This Table: Nightfall bills on seats, apps, and stored data, Protecto on API calls, and Enigma Vault NoPII on protected tokens, so the units are not identical. A company with 2,000 staff and one AI feature will see very different ratios from a 40-person AI startup, and Enigma Vault NoPII’s price covers no workforce DLP.
The Practical Takeaway: Ask each vendor for a written quote at your volume, including overage terms, and compare it with the published Enigma Vault NoPII price. See our list of the best PII tokenization software for LLMs for more price points.
Does Nightfall Compare Itself to Protecto?
No, and Protecto does not compare itself to Nightfall either. Neither vendor publishes a page naming the other, which tells you each sees different rivals.
- Protecto’s comparison pages cover Amazon Bedrock Guardrails, AWS Comprehend, Azure, Google Model Armor, John Snow Labs, Limina, Microsoft Presidio, OpenAI’s privacy filter, Protegrity, and Skyflow, plus generic DLP and guardrails pages.
- Nightfall’s comparison pages cover DLP vendors such as Microsoft Purview and Cyberhaven, plus an alternatives page for Lakera.
- One date to check: Nightfall’s Lakera page dates Check Point’s acquisition of Lakera to October 2025, while Check Point announced it on 16 September 2025.
Treat every vendor-written comparison as marketing, including this one, and let only the claims you can test in a proof of concept count.
Nightfall vs Protecto Reviews
Nightfall has 101 reviews on G2 at 4.6/5 and 2 on Capterra. Protecto is listed on both sites with no reviews. Enigma Vault NoPII has one on G2.
| Source | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| G2 | 4.6/5 from 101 reviews | Listed, no reviews | 5/5 from 1 review |
| Capterra | 5.0/5 from 2 reviews | Listed, no reviews | No listing |
| Other public proof | Named customers such as Grafana, CoreWeave, Snyk, NerdWallet, and BNY Mellon | Vendor-published case studies, such as Bank Muscat | A public live demo |
| Next step | Ratings as of 22 November 2026. Ask every vendor for a reference in your industry. | ||
What Nightfall Reviewers Say
Nightfall’s G2 reviewers praise its AI coverage, ready-made policies, and Slack alerts. The critical notes ask for better reporting, more customizable detectors, and fewer false positives. In November 2026, Nightfall reported record Q3 new ARR, up 3x year over year, a vendor figure.
What Protecto Reviewers Say
Protecto has no third-party reviews on G2 or Capterra, so its evidence is its own: logos including Automation Anywhere, Inovalon, Citrix, and Dell, and case studies such as Bank Muscat. Protecto says Automation Anywhere uses it across more than 5,000 live enterprise tenants. The accuracy figures in these case studies are Protecto’s own, so ask for a reference call.
What Enigma Vault NoPII Reviewers Say
Enigma Vault NoPII has one G2 review, rated 5/5. One review is not a meaningful sample, so we would rather you test it on your own prompts than trust the rating.
Who Should Choose Nightfall, Protecto, or Enigma Vault NoPII
Security Teams Responding to Shadow AI Across the Company
Nightfall fits best. Staff use public AI tools, files sit in Slack and Drive, and the board wants a control in place this quarter. Nightfall covers browsers, endpoints, and SaaS from one console and adds coding-agent control on Premier. Protecto does not address this problem.
If You Build RAG or Agents on Customer Records
Protecto fits best if you need documents masked before they are embedded, tokens in your vector store, and answers unmasked only for the right role. If your copilot is one app calling an LLM API, price Enigma Vault NoPII first.
For Banks and Government Teams That Cannot Send Data to a Vendor Cloud
Protecto’s on-premises and air-gapped options fit, as long as you staff the operations. Nightfall has no on-premises edition we could find. Enigma Vault NoPII self-hosts only on Enterprise.
Startups Adding an LLM Feature on a Small Budget
Nightfall’s proof of value leads to a per-user quote, and Protecto’s trial goes through sales with its price table offline on 22 November. Enigma Vault NoPII’s Lite tier is free to one million protected tokens a month with no expiry, and every paid tier is published, from $49 a month, so you can price your own volume before talking to anyone.
Questions to Ask Nightfall and Protecto Before You Sign
Bring these to both vendors. The answers shown are what each publishes today, so you can see where a sales call is needed.
| Question | Nightfall AI | Protecto | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| What counts toward the bill? | Seats, apps covered, and TB scanned; ask for per-user rates | API calls; ask what one call can carry and confirm the $250 to $750 plans | Protected tokens, published |
| Can we try it before signing? | A free 7-day proof of value | Trial or POC through sales; ask for terms | Yes, on the free Lite tier, with no expiry |
| Which features are live today? | Confirm MCP Gateway enforcement in Premier in writing | Ask about context-based access control and MCP | Listed on the product page |
| Can values be restored? | Only via RSA encryption you manage | Unmask API; ask about per-user policy | Automatic in the response |
| What is the support target? | 1-hour SLA with priority support | Ask for SaaS terms; on-premises targets 1 hour for critical issues | Ask about your plan’s terms |
| Can we see audit reports? | Ask for the SOC 2 report | Ask for the SOC 2 report and ISO certificate | SOC 2 report on request |
| Next step | Put the same questions to Enigma Vault. | ||
The feature row matters most for Protecto, whose marketing and docs disagree in places, and the pricing row matters most for Nightfall, which publishes no figures. Get both answers in writing before you sign.
Moving From Nightfall or Protecto to Enigma Vault NoPII
If you already use either product around model calls, the move is small and reversible, so plan it before you cancel anything.
- List Your Mask, Unmask, and Scan Calls: Find every place your code calls Protecto’s API or Nightfall’s Developer API around a model call.
- Keep What Enigma Vault NoPII Does Not Cover: Workforce DLP, coding-agent hooks, data-at-rest scanning, and file handling stay where they are.
- Route One Provider First: Point one model client at the Enigma Vault NoPII base URL, compare its audit log with your current logs, and remove the wrapper code once replies match.
- Run Both for a Few Weeks: Then cut over the remaining providers.
Our guide to PII masking for LLMs explains the approaches in more detail. If you want help mapping your AI data path, book a migration call.
Final Verdict: Nightfall, Protecto, or Enigma Vault NoPII?
Nightfall and Protecto are built for different jobs. Nightfall is the stronger choice when the risk is people and their tools sending data out through public AI apps, SaaS, endpoints, and coding agents.
Protecto is the stronger choice when you build RAG and agent systems that must use sensitive data, restore it for the right users, and may need to run inside your own network. I’d decide on the job first and the price second, and many larger companies will end up with one of each.
If you want published prices, a free start, and PII kept out of your own app’s LLM calls with real values in every reply, Enigma Vault NoPII covers that. It has no workforce DLP and no on-premises option below Enterprise, so if your project depends on either, it is not the right choice.
See what reaches your model provider.
Book a demo and we will tell you honestly whether Nightfall, Protecto, or Enigma Vault NoPII fits, or explore Enigma Vault NoPII first.
More comparisons: Nightfall vs Limina, Nightfall vs Lakera, Protecto vs Skyflow, and Enigma Vault NoPII vs Protecto.
How We Researched This Comparison
We checked every fact again from the primary sources on 22 November 2026; Protecto’s withdrawn price table is confirmed from an archived copy of its SaaS page. Nightfall facts come from nightfall.ai, its pricing, security, and product pages, its Lakera alternatives page, and its help center.
Protecto facts come from protecto.ai, its SaaS and comparison pages, its docs and roadmap, its support SLA, and its case studies. G2 and Capterra reviews and listings are third-party, read live on 22 November 2026, and Enigma Vault NoPII facts come from our own product and pricing pages.
Where a vendor makes a claim about itself or a rival, such as detection accuracy or growth, we label it as a vendor claim. If something here is out of date, tell us through our contact page and we will check it.