Nightfall and Lakera both appear on AI security shortlists, and both keep names, account numbers, credentials, and other sensitive data from leaking through AI. Lakera here is the guardrail company now owned by Check Point and documented as Check Point AI Guardrails and Check Point AI Agent Security.
Nightfall is best for security teams that want data loss prevention across employees, SaaS apps, endpoints, and AI tools, while Lakera is best for teams shipping AI apps that need runtime defense against prompt attacks. This guide compares Nightfall and Lakera on architecture, features, pricing, compliance, and reviews, with Enigma Vault NoPII, our LLM privacy proxy, alongside as a free-to-start third option.
Nightfall vs Lakera at a Glance
| Vendor | Nightfall AI | Lakera (Check Point) | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Security teams stopping data loss across the workforce and its AI tools | Teams shipping AI apps and agents that need prompt-attack defense | Teams protecting their own app’s LLM calls with a base-URL change |
| Entry price | Per user per year, by quote | Free sign-up; prices not shown | Free, then $49/mo |
| Free option | Free 7-day proof of value with a security assessment report | Free platform sign-up | Lite: 1M protected tokens a month, no expiry |
| Architecture | Browser plugins, an endpoint agent, SaaS connectors, and a scan API | Guard API called by your app on each interaction | Hosted proxy: change the model base URL |
| Deployment | SaaS in Nightfall’s cloud, with agents on your devices | SaaS in EU, US, or Singapore, or self-hosted, including air-gapped | Managed cloud; self-hosted edition on Enterprise |
| G2 | 4.6/5 (101) | 4.2/5 (12), as Check Point AI Agent Security | 5.0/5 (1) |
| Next step | One million protected tokens a month free. No card needed. | ||
Review figures are as of 22 November 2026, and vendor facts were rechecked on 22 November 2026 from each vendor’s own site and docs. For more options, see our guide to Nightfall alternatives and our list of the best AI data security software for enterprises.
Nightfall vs Lakera: Quick Verdict
Nightfall AI: An AI-native data loss prevention platform. Browser plugins and a macOS and Windows agent watch copy and paste, uploads, and prompts into tools such as ChatGPT, Claude, and Copilot, and connectors cover SaaS apps such as Slack, Google Drive, and GitHub. Premier adds hooks for coding assistants and MCP discovery. It is sold per user per year by quote, after a free proof of value.
Lakera: A runtime guardrail. Check Point announced its acquisition of Lakera on 16 September 2025, and Lakera’s docs now name the products Check Point AI Guardrails and Check Point AI Agent Security, while lakera.ai still runs with a Check Point footer.
Your app calls the Guard API on each interaction, and it screens for prompt attacks, data leakage, content violations, and malicious links. It claims sub-50 millisecond latency and can be self-hosted, including air-gapped.
Enigma Vault NoPII: A hosted proxy. You change your model client’s base URL, and Enigma Vault NoPII tokenizes PII before it reaches the model provider and restores it in the response. It is free for one million protected tokens a month, then $49, $249, and $499. Self-hosting is available on the Enterprise plan.
Nightfall is the better fit if:
- Your main risk is employees pasting sensitive data into AI tools or oversharing in SaaS apps.
- You want coaching, blocking, and alerts across browsers, endpoints, and email from one console.
- You are watching coding assistants and MCP servers on developer machines.
Lakera is the better fit if:
- Your main risk is attackers manipulating the chatbots, copilots, or agents you ship.
- Guardrails must run inside your own infrastructure, including air-gapped.
- You already buy from Check Point and want AI security in the same estate.
Enigma Vault NoPII is the better fit if:
- Your app sends customer data to an LLM provider, and the reply still needs the real names and numbers.
- You want a published price and a free tier that does not expire, so you can prove it on real traffic first.
- You can handle workforce DLP and prompt-attack defense with other tools.
Where this leaves you: Nightfall guards what your people send out, Lakera guards the AI apps you ship, and Enigma Vault NoPII protects your application’s LLM calls with a base-URL change and a price you can read.
How Nightfall, Lakera, and Enigma Vault NoPII Differ at the Core
Nightfall sits on laptops, in browsers, and inside SaaS tenants and watches what people do with data, Lakera screens each interaction your AI app sends it and returns a verdict, and Enigma Vault NoPII sits in the path of your LLM requests and does the swap for you.
To make it concrete, follow five common situations and see which product handles each.
| Situation | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. An employee pastes a customer list into ChatGPT | Covered by browser plugins and the endpoint agent | Not covered | Not covered |
| 2. A developer’s coding assistant reads a file with secrets | Covered on Premier with Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code hooks | Not covered | Not covered |
| 3. A user tries to jailbreak your support chatbot | Not its job; its prompt injection detector runs on endpoints | Covered: prompt-attack detection on each request | Not covered |
| 4. Your app sends a ticket with a name and email to OpenAI | Possible if you call its scan API first | Detected; your app blocks or masks it | Covered: tokenized, then restored in the reply |
| 5. An agent’s tool call returns a customer record | MCP discovery and policy on Premier | Tool messages and tool calls are screened | Tool results in the request are tokenized before the model reads them |
| Next step | Most companies with AI features have more than one of these rows. Enigma Vault NoPII’s free Lite tier covers one million protected tokens a month. | ||
Nightfall’s Model: The outbound path from people. It sees what employees do with data whether or not your company built any AI, and it remediates through coaching, blocking, and alerts.
Lakera’s Model: The inbound path to your AI apps. It only sees what your application sends it, so it protects products you build and nothing your staff does in third-party tools.
Enigma Vault NoPII’s Model: The proxy sits in the request path from your app to the model provider, so there is nothing to call at each boundary. The trade-off is that it only sees traffic you route through it.
Nightfall vs Lakera Pricing
What Nightfall Charges
Nightfall’s pricing page lists two editions priced per user per year, with the amounts left blank. There is no self-serve trial; Nightfall offers a free 7-day proof of value in your own environment, which ends with a security assessment report.
| Nightfall edition | What you get |
|---|---|
| Foundation, per user per year | Detection and response across SaaS apps, exfiltration prevention through the endpoint agent, 150 GB of data-at-rest scanning, 2 endpoint devices per user, a customer success manager, and a one-hour priority support commitment |
| Premier, per user per year | Everything in Foundation, in two tiers (up to 3 apps, or all supported apps), plus hooks for Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code, MCP discovery and shadow-MCP detection, Claude Enterprise compliance monitoring, SIEM export, and Jamf or Intune deployment |
| Data discovery add-on | Annual packs of 1, 3, 5, or 20 TB beyond the included 150 GB; prices not listed |
Compare: Enigma Vault NoPII is free for one million protected tokens a month, then $49, $249, and $499. | |
Because the unit is the user, Nightfall’s bill grows with headcount, whatever your AI app traffic does. Capterra shows a starting price of $4 per feature per month, which does not match Nightfall’s own per-user model, so treat it as unconfirmed.
What Lakera Charges
Lakera publishes no plans or prices. The pricing link on lakera.ai goes nowhere, and platform.lakera.ai/pricing showed no plan prices or request limits when we checked on 22 November 2026. A free sign-up gives you access to the platform, and self-hosting needs an Enterprise license. Under Check Point, expect production pricing to come through a quote, and possibly through a wider Check Point agreement.
What Enigma Vault NoPII Charges
Enigma Vault NoPII bills on protected tokens, which means anything in a request or response that flows through the proxy. Lite is free for one million a month with no card and no expiry. Starter is $49 for 50 million, Growth is $249 for 500 million, and Business is $499 for 2 billion, with overage at $1.00, $0.80, and $0.60 per additional million.
Yearly prices are $550, $2,700, and $5,500. Enterprise is custom and includes the self-hosted edition and a BAA.
Nightfall vs Lakera Cost at Four Stages
| Stage | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Trying it out | Free proof of value or assessment, run with Nightfall | Free platform sign-up | Lite: 1M protected tokens a month, self-serve |
| First production feature | Foundation, quote per user per year | Quote | $0 on Lite, or $49/mo on Starter (50M tokens) |
| Growing workload | Bill grows with headcount and scanned data | Ask how requests or apps are metered | $249/mo (Growth, 500M tokens) |
| Large or regulated deployment | Premier, all apps, plus data packs | Enterprise license, including self-hosting | $499/mo (Business, 2B tokens), or Enterprise with self-hosting |
| Next step | The units differ: users, unpublished request terms, and protected tokens. Run your own traffic through each. | ||
How to Read This Table: The rows show stage, not equal spend. Nightfall prices people, Lakera has not published how it meters, and Enigma Vault NoPII prices traffic through the proxy. A company with many employees and one small AI feature will see a very different ratio than an AI-first startup with 20 staff and heavy model traffic.
The Practical Takeaway: Ask Nightfall for a quote at your headcount, ask Lakera (or Check Point) what one million guarded requests a month costs, and run the same month of LLM traffic through the Enigma Vault NoPII free tier. A year of Enigma Vault NoPII Starter is $550 and Growth is $2,700. See our list of the best PII tokenization software for LLMs for more options.
Nightfall vs Lakera Features Compared
Compare Nightfall and Lakera on how they protect LLM data, what they detect, where they run, and how they respond to a finding. Nightfall covers far more channels, Lakera goes deeper on attacks against AI apps, and their overlap is narrower than the shortlists suggest.
| Feature | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core approach | Detect, then block, redact, coach, or alert | Screen each interaction, then block or flag | Reversible tokenization in a proxy |
| Integration effort | Browser plugins, endpoint agent, SaaS connectors, or a scan API call before each model call | A Guard API call on each interaction | Change the base URL |
| PII detection | ML detectors for PII, PHI, secrets, credentials, and financial data, plus custom regex and word lists | Eight PII detectors, plus custom entities | 11 on by default, 25+ opt-in, and 14 credential families |
| What happens to PII | Mask, substitute, remove, or encrypt with your key | Block, or mask detected values | Consistent tokens, restored automatically |
| Languages | Not compared in our sources | 100+ for screening (vendor claim) | Pattern-based types work in most languages |
| Prompt attacks | Prompt injection interception in employee AI use | Core feature | Not offered |
| Content and links | Detectors for secrets, source code, and PII; content categories not published | Content violations and malicious links | Not offered |
| Employee AI tools | ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot, and more | Not covered | Not covered |
| SaaS, email, and endpoints | 12+ SaaS apps, email, macOS and Windows | Not covered | Not covered |
| Agents and MCP | MCP discovery and shadow-MCP detection on Premier | Tool calls screened; agent discovery in AI Agent Security | Tool results in requests tokenized |
| Modalities | Text and files | Text; audio in early access; images listed as coming soon | Text only |
| Deployment | SaaS, browser plugins, endpoint agent | SaaS in EU, US, and Singapore, or self-hosted | Managed; self-hosted on Enterprise |
| Next step | Ask each vendor which features are in your edition or license, and what is generally available today. | ||
Here is how the biggest differences play out in practice.
Where Nightfall and Lakera Differ in Practice
How Each Protects LLM Data
Lakera’s Guard response can include the type and start and end positions of each detected value. Its docs say it can block the interaction or mask the data, but nothing in them describes putting real values back into a reply.
Nightfall’s scan API goes further on the redaction side: it can mask characters, substitute a phrase or the detector name, return only the redacted finding, or encrypt it with your own key. Getting the original values back still means decrypting with your own key in your own code.
Enigma Vault NoPII keeps the same token for the same value across a conversation and restores real values in the response, including streamed output. If tokenization fails, the request is blocked instead of being sent raw.
Detection Coverage and Accuracy Claims
Lakera lists eight built-in PII detectors: full names, US addresses and phone numbers, email and IP addresses, card numbers (Luhn-validated), IBANs, and US Social Security numbers, plus custom entities.
It does not list secrets or API keys as PII. The list is short and US-centric, which fits a product whose main job is attack defense, so if you serve users in Europe, India, or Asia-Pacific, ask how custom entities would cover national IDs and local formats.
Nightfall’s library covers PII, PHI, secrets, API keys, passwords, connection strings, and US SSN, with custom regex, word lists, and trainable detection on top.
Nightfall advertises 95% detection precision, which it says comes from customer data in limited proofs of value. Lakera claims a 0.01% production false positive rate on its homepage, and its integration guide recommends calibrating on about 6,000 representative data points. These are vendor figures on different traffic. No independent head-to-head exists, so run both on your own data.
Deployment: Your Network or Theirs
Lakera runs as SaaS with regional endpoints in the EU, US, and Singapore, stores logs in the EU by default, and can be self-hosted on Kubernetes or Docker, including air-gapped, with an Enterprise license. The storage region is set when the organization is created and cannot be changed later.
Nightfall runs in its own cloud, with browser plugins and an endpoint agent deployed to your devices through Jamf or Intune on Premier. We found no customer-hosted option in its docs. Enigma Vault NoPII is a managed service, and its self-hosted edition runs under an Enterprise license.
Remediation, Ownership, and What Is Still on the Roadmap
Nightfall’s remediation is human-facing: it can coach an employee in the moment, notify them on their device, alert a security analyst in Slack, Teams, email, or Jira, and push findings to a SIEM. Lakera’s remediation is machine-facing: a verdict comes back to your app, which blocks or continues, and Lakera claims sub-50 millisecond latency for that check.
Lakera’s ownership also changes the buying conversation. You may now buy through an existing Check Point contract or reseller, Check Point’s portfolio includes workforce AI controls and agent discovery that may be bundled, and G2 reviewers mention pricing that can feel steep for smaller setups.
The Guard API, regional endpoints, and self-hosted option are still documented, while audio is in early access and images are listed as coming soon. Ask for the roadmap and support terms in writing.
Enigma Vault NoPII keeps an audit log of every token with entity type, provider, and model, and never stores plaintext. It is sold and supported by Enigma Vault directly.
Agents, RAG, and MCP
Nightfall’s Premier edition adds hooks for Cursor, Claude Code, and VS Code, MCP discovery, and shadow-MCP detection, which watch what coding assistants and MCP servers do on developer machines.
Lakera screens tool messages and tool calls in the apps you build and flags off-policy agent behavior, and Check Point AI Agent Security adds agent discovery. Enigma Vault NoPII tokenizes anything your app puts in a request, including retrieved context and tool results, before the model reads it.
Prompt Attacks and Jailbreaks
Lakera is built around prompt-attack defense. Its homepage says it learns from 1M+ hackers around the world, and its old Gandalf game address now leads to Agent Breaker, a public game for testing AI hacking skills.
Nightfall’s prompt injection detector runs in its macOS and Windows endpoint integrations, where it watches employee use of AI tools. If attackers reaching your own chatbot is the threat, Lakera is the specialist. Enigma Vault NoPII does not detect prompt injection.
Nightfall vs Lakera Security and Compliance
Nightfall states SOC 2 Type 2 on its security page, and its pricing FAQ adds ISO 27001 and calls it HIPAA-ready and GDPR-compliant. We found no compliance list on Lakera’s pages; with Check Point as owner, ask which Check Point reports cover the guardrail service. Enigma Vault NoPII runs on Enigma Vault’s platform, which is PCI DSS Level 1 and SOC 2 Type II.
| Control | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| SOC 2 | Type 2, on its security page | Not found on its pages | Type II (Enigma Vault platform) |
| ISO 27001 | Stated in its pricing FAQ; not on its security page | Not found on its pages | In progress |
| HIPAA | “HIPAA-ready” per its pricing FAQ; ask about a BAA | Not found | BAA on Enterprise |
| Data residency | US hosting named on its security page | EU, US, or Singapore; EU by default; or self-hosted | Enigma Vault NoPII Cloud, or your environment on Enterprise |
| Logged PII | Findings shown in alerts and sent to SIEM | Detected PII masked before logging; not used for training | Audit log never stores plaintext |
| Next step | Ask every vendor who operates the service and what audit evidence it can share. | ||
DLP tools by nature store evidence of what they caught, so ask Nightfall how long findings and their snippets are kept and where. Whichever you choose, ask for the audit documents under NDA before you send production data.
Nightfall vs Lakera Reviews
Nightfall has a solid G2 sample. Lakera’s reviews now sit under a Check Point listing that covers the wider agent security product, so they say less about the guardrail alone. Enigma Vault NoPII has one.
| Source | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| G2 | 4.6/5 from 101 reviews | 4.2/5 from 12, as Check Point AI Agent Security | 5.0/5 from 1 review |
| Capterra | 5.0/5 from 2 reviews | No listing found | No listing |
| Next step | Ratings as of 22 November 2026. Test detection on your own prompts. | ||
What Nightfall’s Proof Shows
Nightfall reviewers praise its coverage of AI tools, strong out-of-the-box policies, and Slack alerts that make triage quick. Critics ask for better reporting and filters and mention false positives that needed policy tuning.
What Lakera’s Proof Shows
Reviewers of Check Point AI Agent Security like its discovery of AI agents and real-time control of agent actions. They mention a learning curve, time spent tuning policies, a product one reviewer calls not yet mature, and pricing that feels steep for smaller setups.
What Enigma Vault NoPII’s Proof Shows
The one G2 reviewer values that tokenization keeps context that redaction loses and that setup took two lines of code, and finds the interface clunky. One review is not a sample, so test the free tier on your own prompts.
What Nightfall’s Comparison Page Says About Lakera
Nightfall published a Lakera alternatives guide dated 3 November 2026. It ranks seven options: Nightfall first, then HiddenLayer, Prompt Security (SentinelOne), Cyberhaven, Microsoft Purview, Varonis, and Forcepoint, with each section ending in a “Nightfall Differentiation” note. Several claims are worth checking.
- Check Point acquired Lakera in October 2025: Check Point’s announcement is dated 16 September 2025. The month is wrong, though the acquisition itself is right.
- Lakera is mainly a runtime guardrail for prompt injection in custom LLM apps: Broadly fair. Lakera’s docs also cover data leakage, content violations, malicious links, and agent behavior.
- Buyers need coverage beyond runtime screening: True for workforce risk, which Lakera never claimed to cover. It is an argument about category, and it says nothing about how well Lakera does its own job.
- Nightfall covers 12+ SaaS apps, endpoints, email, browsers, and AI agents: Consistent with Nightfall’s product and pricing pages.
- 95% detection precision, SOC 2 Type II, and ISO 27001: The precision figure comes from limited proofs of value on customer data, with no independent test cited, and the certifications are stated by Nightfall. Ask for the report and certificate.
The page also notes that roadmaps and packaging often change after an acquisition. That is a general point, with no evidence of any change at Lakera, though it is a fair question to ask Check Point. Treat the page as marketing, and let only the claims you can test in a proof of concept count.
Does Lakera Compare Itself to Nightfall?
No. We found no Lakera or Check Point page comparing the guardrail with Nightfall. That fits the products: Lakera positions itself against other AI runtime tools, while Nightfall’s page reaches for Lakera’s buyers. That leaves Nightfall’s guide as the only head-to-head between the two, so every claim above comes from one side. Ask each vendor to show the claims it makes in a proof of concept.
Who Should Choose Nightfall, Lakera, or Enigma Vault NoPII
AI Product Teams Calling an LLM API From One Application
Enigma Vault NoPII is the shortest path: change the base URL, test on the free tier, and read the audit log. A support summary or draft email has to say “Dear Maria,” not “Dear [NAME],” and real values come back in the reply with no restore code on your side.
If Processing Must Stay Inside Your Own Network
Lakera’s self-hosted option on Kubernetes or Docker, including air-gapped, is built for this, under an Enterprise license. Nightfall has no customer-hosted option we could find. Enigma Vault NoPII’s self-hosted edition is available on Enterprise. In every case, ask who operates the service and what the audit evidence looks like.
Enterprises Facing Shadow AI Across the Workforce
Nightfall fits best. Browser plugins, endpoint agents, and SaaS connectors see what staff paste into ChatGPT, Claude, and Copilot, and coaching changes behavior without blanket bans. Lakera does not see this traffic at all. Expect a proof of value, a quote per user, and an annual contract.
For Defending a Public AI App From Prompt Attacks
Lakera fits. Each user message and model reply goes through the Guard API, and attack detection is the product’s core. If you already buy from Check Point, it may be the path of least resistance. Pair it with a way to handle PII in the same calls, since Lakera blocks or masks PII but does not restore it.
Questions to Ask Nightfall and Lakera Before You Sign
Bring these to both vendors. The answers shown are what each publishes today, so you can see where a sales call is needed.
| Question | Nightfall AI | Lakera | Also considerEnigma Vault NoPII |
|---|---|---|---|
| What will it cost at our size, and in what unit? | Quote per user per year; ask about data packs | Quote; ask how requests are metered | Published; counts protected tokens through the proxy |
| Can we try it with real traffic? | Proof of value run with Nightfall | Free sign-up; ask about limits | Yes: Lite is free indefinitely at 1M tokens a month |
| Which PII types are covered? | Ask for the detector list in your edition | Eight built-in; ask about non-US identifiers | Listed by market on the product page |
| Can we get real values back in responses? | Only by decrypting with your own key | Not documented | Yes, automatically |
| Which compliance reports cover this service? | SOC 2 Type 2 and ISO 27001 stated | Ask which Check Point reports apply | SOC 2 Type II; ISO 27001 in progress |
| Who supports us next year? | Nightfall | Ask how Check Point packages and supports Lakera | Enigma Vault |
| Next step | Put the same questions to Enigma Vault. | ||
The last row matters more than usual here. Lakera changed owners in 2025, so agree support terms and the roadmap in writing before you sign.
Moving From Nightfall or Lakera to Enigma Vault NoPII
This applies only to the PII handling in your own app’s LLM calls. Workforce DLP and prompt-attack defense are separate jobs that do not need to move.
- Find Your Scan or Guard Calls: List each place your app calls Nightfall’s scan API or Lakera’s Guard API before a model call, and any masking code that follows.
- Keep What Still Fits: Leave Lakera’s attack screening and Nightfall’s workforce coverage in place.
- Route One Provider First: Point one model client at the Enigma Vault NoPII base URL and compare what reaches the provider in the audit log.
- Remove Your Own Masking Code: Once results match, drop the masking and restore logic on that path.
If you want help mapping your AI data path, book a migration call, or read our guide to LLM privacy proxies.
Final Verdict: Nightfall, Lakera, or Enigma Vault NoPII?
Nightfall and Lakera solve neighboring problems from different directions. Nightfall is the stronger choice when your risk is people: employees sharing data with AI tools, SaaS apps, and coding assistants.
Lakera is the stronger choice when your risk is attacks on the AI apps you ship, especially if guardrails must run inside your network, and its Check Point ownership is a plus if you already buy there. I’d map where data leaves your company first and the price second.
If what you need is to keep PII out of your application’s LLM calls without breaking the answer, Enigma Vault NoPII does that with a base-URL change, a price you can read, and a free tier that does not expire. It does not monitor employees or stop prompt injection, so if your project depends on those, it is not the right choice.
See what reaches your model provider.
Book a demo to map your AI data path, or explore Enigma Vault NoPII first. The free tier covers one million protected tokens a month.
More comparisons: Nightfall vs Skyflow, Nightfall vs Protecto, Nightfall vs Limina, and Enigma Vault NoPII vs Nightfall.
How We Researched This Comparison
We checked every vendor fact again from scratch on 22 November 2026.
Nightfall facts come from nightfall.ai, its pricing and product pages, its help center, and its Lakera alternatives guide. Lakera facts come from lakera.ai, its docs, its platform pricing page, and Check Point’s newsroom and AI security pages. Review data comes from G2 and Capterra, read live on 22 November 2026, and Enigma Vault NoPII facts come from our own product and pricing pages.
Where a vendor makes a claim about itself or a rival, such as accuracy or latency, we label it as a vendor claim. Enigma Vault publishes this page, so read it as a vendor-written comparison. If something here is out of date, tell us through our contact page and we will check it.