Very Good Security (VGS) and TokenEx are both processor-agnostic tokenization platforms that keep card numbers out of your own systems, VGS through a standalone vault and proxy and TokenEx through Universal Tokens inside IXOPAY’s payment orchestration platform.
This guide compares VGS and TokenEx on architecture, features, pricing, compliance, and reviews, with Enigma Vault alongside as a third option for teams that want published prices and a simpler start.
VGS is best for online businesses and fintechs that want a vault with card lifecycle tools, while TokenEx is best for enterprise and omnichannel merchants that want tokens and routing from one vendor.
VGS vs TokenEx at a Glance
| Vendor | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Online businesses and fintechs that want a vault with card lifecycle tools | Enterprise and omnichannel merchants that want tokens and routing from one vendor | Teams that want PCI scope reduction at published prices |
| Entry price | From $1,000/mo (Starter) | Quote only | Free, then $49/mo |
| Free option | Free sandbox, not for real card data | Sandbox by request | Free Lite sandbox, with hard limits |
| Architecture | Standalone vault and proxy | Universal Tokens inside IXO One (orchestration, intelligence, tokenization) | Card Vault plus an allowlisted gateway proxy |
| G2 | 4.7/5 (47) | 4.6/5 (17) | 4.4/5 (6) |
| Capterra | Listed, 0 reviews | Listed, 0 reviews | 4.8/5 (4) |
| Next step | Free Lite sandbox on Card Vault. Published plans from $49 a month. | ||
Vendor facts were checked on 22 November 2026 on each vendor’s own site, and G2 and Capterra figures are as of 22 November 2026. For more options, see our guides to Very Good Security alternatives and TokenEx alternatives.
VGS vs TokenEx: Quick Verdict
VGS: A processor-agnostic vault that collects card data through hosted forms and native mobile SDKs, intercepts it before it reaches your servers, and restores the real values on the way to your processor. Around the vault it sells network tokens, account updater, card attributes, VGS Compute, and a PCI compliance subscription with a VGS-provided auditor. Starter plans start at $1,000 a month, and Growth is by quote.
TokenEx: IXOPAY’s tokenization platform. TokenEx’s homepage now calls it “the tokenization platform from IXOPAY,” so contracts, support, and roadmap run through IXOPAY. TokenEx Vault secures payment, PII, and health data, and IXOPAY sells it as Universal Tokens inside IXO One, which adds orchestration across 250+ acquirers and 300+ payment methods, AI payments intelligence, and in-store P2PE. Prices are by quote.
Enigma Vault: A PCI DSS Level 1 tokenization service with a free Lite sandbox and Card Vault plans of $49, $249, and $499 a month. It adds phone card capture through Twilio Pay and charges through the gateway you already use, without network tokens, account updater, or routing.
Pick VGS when:
- Your cards arrive online or in apps, and you want a vault that stays separate from whoever routes your payments.
- You want network tokens, account updater, and card attributes from the same vendor that holds your cards.
- You want audit help, since its Growth package lists a PCI compliance subscription and a VGS-provided auditor.
Pick TokenEx when:
- You already plan to adopt payment orchestration and want tokenization from the same platform.
- You take cards in stores as well as online and want one token across channels, with P2PE at the terminal.
- You protect PII and health records as well as cards and want one vault for all of them.
Pick Enigma Vault when:
- You want published prices and a free tier before any sales process.
- Cards reach you by phone, and you want an IVR that keeps them off the call.
- You can live without network tokens, account updater, routing, and card-present encryption.
In short: VGS sells the vault as its own product, TokenEx sells tokenization and routing together through IXOPAY, and Enigma Vault covers PCI scope reduction at published prices for teams that need neither vendor’s depth.
How VGS and TokenEx Differ at the Core
VGS keeps your cards in a standalone vault and puts a proxy in front of your traffic, leaving routing to your code or gateway, whereas TokenEx keeps cards in a vault that IXOPAY can also route across acquirers, if you buy that module.
To make it concrete, follow one retail customer. They save a card at online checkout, tap the same card in a store, call support to update a payment, and later get charged through a second processor.
| Piece of data | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| Card saved at online checkout | Hosted collect forms or native mobile SDKs | Hosted iFrame, browser-based encryption, or Mobile API | Hosted forms or API |
| Same card tapped in a store | No card-present product listed; pair with an in-store provider | PCI-validated P2PE, mapped to the same customer token | Not offered |
| Card read out on a support call | Not listed | Not listed | Twilio Pay IVR (from Growth) |
| Charge on a second processor | Outbound route restores values in transit | Transparent Gateway or one of 500+ prebuilt adapters | Allowlisted gateway proxy |
| Who decides routing and retries | Your code or your gateway | IXOPAY’s orchestration rules, if you buy that module | Your code |
| Next step | VGS’s sandbox, TokenEx’s sandbox on request, and Enigma Vault’s Lite tier are all test environments. Enigma Vault’s first paid plan is $49 a month. | ||
VGS’s Model: One independent vault, with routes that decide which values are swapped and restored. VGS describes itself as “the world’s leading independent network token vault” on its comparison page. If your routing needs change, your stored cards stay where they are, and only routing code changes.
TokenEx’s Model: One vendor for tokens and, optionally, routing. IXOPAY says businesses can “buy what they need and build what they want,” and says its tokens are merchant-owned and work with any gateway or acquirer that accepts them. It also cites $200B in transactions orchestrated and 2B+ payment events analyzed by AI. Tokens and routing sit with one vendor, so a later move means planning both together.
Enigma Vault’s Model: A card vault with a gateway proxy that charges through whichever REST gateway you allowlist, so switching processors is a configuration change. It does not route or retry for you.
If you have one or two processors and no plans for routing logic, VGS’s model fits and the orchestration half of IXO One adds little. If you run five or more acquirers across regions, or stores alongside ecommerce, TokenEx’s model fits. If cards still arrive by phone and price matters most, Enigma Vault’s model fits.
VGS vs TokenEx Security and Compliance
VGS and Enigma Vault both list PCI DSS and SOC 2, and VGS also lists ISO/IEC 27001:2022, which Enigma Vault is still working toward. IXOPAY publishes no audit level or certification list on the pages we read, but it alone offers a PCI-validated P2PE solution.
| Control | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| PCI DSS | v4.0.1 in its Trust Center | Level not published on the pages we read; pages reference PCI DSS 4.0 | Level 1 Service Provider |
| Card-present | Not listed | PCI-validated P2PE | Not offered |
| SOC 2 | Listed in its Trust Center | Not published on the pages we read; ask the vendor | Type II |
| ISO 27001 | ISO/IEC 27001:2022 | Not published on the pages we read; ask the vendor | In progress |
| HIPAA | Ask about a BAA | Vault covers PHI; ask about a BAA | BAA available |
| Data centers | Not named on the pages we read | Not published on the pages we read | US and EU (EU residency add-on from Growth) |
| Trust documents | Trust Center with gated document access | Ask the vendor | AOC and SOC 2 report from Starter |
| Next step | Ask both vendors for current audit reports and a signed BAA before you send PHI. | ||
VGS’s certifications come from its Trust Center. As of 22 November 2026, IXOPAY’s former security page returns a 404, and the TokenEx and IXOPAY pages we read reference PCI DSS 4.0 and PCI-validated P2PE but publish no audit level, SOC 2, or ISO 27001 status, so request current reports.
Enigma Vault deletes CVV within 30 minutes of capture. With any of the three, the vault can significantly reduce the systems in your PCI scope, but your acquirer or QSA confirms your final scope.
VGS vs TokenEx Features Compared
Compare VGS and TokenEx on data scope, payments tools, routing, channels, and audit help. VGS goes deeper on card lifecycle tools around the vault, TokenEx goes wider on routing, channels, and data types through IXO One, and both leave some capabilities to a sales conversation.
| Feature | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core model | Standalone vault with inbound and outbound routes | Universal Tokens inside IXO One | Card Vault plus gateway proxy |
| Data types | Cards, bank data, and other sensitive fields | Payment (PCI), PII, health (PHI), other elements | Separate Card, Data, File, and Customer Vaults |
| Proxy to processors | Inbound and outbound routes | Transparent Gateway to any processor, gateway, or API | Gateway proxy with a domain allowlist |
| Prebuilt connections | Reach any endpoint through the proxy | 500+ payment adapters | Any REST gateway through the proxy |
| Web and mobile capture | Hosted collect forms; native iOS and Android SDKs | Hosted iFrame, browser-based encryption, Mobile API | Hosted forms and API |
| Files and batch | Large file transfers on Growth | Batch tokenization | Data Vault and File Vault |
| In-store terminals | Not listed | PCI-validated P2PE | Not offered |
| Phone (IVR) capture | Not listed | Not listed | Twilio Pay (from Growth) |
| Network tokens | Growth package | Provisioning and lifecycle management | Not offered |
| Account updater | Growth package | Standalone or with orchestration | Not offered |
| Card attributes | Growth package | BIN lookup | Not offered |
| Orchestration and retries | Not offered | 250+ acquirers, 300+ methods | Not offered |
| Payments analytics | Not listed | AI payments intelligence | Not offered |
| Custom code in the vault | VGS Compute | Not listed | Not offered |
| Audit help | PCI subscription and provided auditor on Growth | Ask IXOPAY | AOC and SOC 2 report from Starter |
| Token format | Aliases | Universal Tokens | Random or Luhn-passable |
| Next step | Check which features each vendor ships in the package you would buy. | ||
Here is how the biggest differences play out in practice.
Where VGS and TokenEx Differ in Practice
Payment Routing and Orchestration
This is TokenEx’s home ground. On IXOPAY’s own site, tokenization appears as Universal Tokens, one of three areas of IXO One, next to orchestration across 250+ acquirers and 300+ payment methods and AI payments intelligence. One vendor means one integration, one contract, and one place to see approval rates across processors, and orchestration can retry a declined payment across providers.
VGS keeps you processor-agnostic, so you can send the same card to different processors, but it does not sell a routing or retry engine. Routing rules stay in your own code or your gateway. Adding a processor means configuring an outbound route and writing the call, while with TokenEx you can use the Transparent Gateway the same way or one of IXOPAY’s prebuilt adapters, where the integration already exists.
If you only want a vault, ask IXOPAY plainly whether Universal Tokens can be bought without orchestration and what the price difference is. Its homepage says you pay for the capabilities and usage you need, which suggests it can, but it publishes no package list.
Enigma Vault also keeps you processor-independent: the gateway proxy charges through whichever REST gateway you allowlist. Like VGS, it does not route or retry for you.
Payments Depth
Both vendors provision network tokens. VGS bundles them with account updater and card attributes in its Growth package and markets direct connections to all four card networks. IXOPAY provisions and manages network tokens inside Universal Tokens and says its tokens can be used with any gateway or acquirer. It also sells account updater, standalone or inside orchestration, and a BIN lookup that returns card attributes.
The practical question is where you want network token lifecycle to live: with the vault that holds your cards, or with the platform that also routes them. Ask each vendor for coverage by card network and region, and to demonstrate the specific features you will use.
In-Store and Phone Payments
IXOPAY says its P2PE solution for in-person payments is PCI-validated, and that tokens can unify payment data across in-person and online channels. For a retailer with stores and ecommerce, a card tapped at a terminal and a card typed at checkout can map to the same customer token.
VGS’s pages focus on online, in-app, and file-based card data, so if you run terminals, you would pair VGS with a separate in-store provider and reconcile tokens yourself.
Phone is the gap neither covers. Agencies, clinics, and support teams that still take card numbers over the phone end up reading them into a web form, which brings agents and call recordings into PCI scope. See our list of card tokenization software for travel agencies for how phone capture changes the shortlist.
Enigma Vault’s Card Vault captures cards over the phone through Twilio Pay IVR from Growth, so card numbers stay off the call. It does not cover in-store terminals.
Health Records and PII
IXOPAY lists payment data, PII, and PHI as data types for the TokenEx vault, which helps if you are a healthcare or insurance business that takes payments. VGS’s vault also protects non-card fields such as bank details, and its pages focus on payments and fintech. If PHI matters, ask both whether they sign a BAA and under which plan.
Enigma Vault keeps non-card records in a separate Data Vault and files in File Vault, and it offers a BAA for healthcare workloads.
Custom Logic and Audit Help
VGS Compute, listed on Growth, lets you run your own logic on sensitive data inside VGS’s environment. We found no equivalent on TokenEx’s or IXOPAY’s pages; IXOPAY’s answer to custom logic is orchestration rules and its payments intelligence. If you need to transform card data in ways your processor does not support, VGS has the clearer story.
On audits, IXOPAY says its tokens can “eliminate up to 90% of PCI DSS requirements” and that its P2PE solution is PCI-validated. VGS sells the audit help itself: a PCI compliance subscription for Level 1 and Levels 2 to 4 and a VGS-provided auditor, both listed on Growth. Neither vendor’s claim replaces your acquirer’s or QSA’s view of your final scope.
Time to First Token and Support
VGS lets you create a free sandbox straight from its pricing page, though it is not for real card data. TokenEx sandbox access comes through a request form. G2 users report about four months to implement VGS and about one month for TokenEx, as of 22 November 2026; these are small samples, and both depend on how many channels and processors you connect.
On support, neither vendor publishes support tiers on the pages we read. G2 reviewers praise VGS’s support, and TokenEx reviewers mention quick responses to tickets.
VGS vs TokenEx Pricing
What VGS Charges
VGS’s pricing page shows two packages. Starter says “Plans start at $1,000/month” and lists no included features, units, or overage. Growth has no price, and its card lists network tokens, account updater, a PCI compliance subscription for Level 1 and Levels 2 to 4, a VGS-provided auditor, large file transfers, VGS Compute, and card attributes.
Vendr, which tracks software purchases, shows a median of $56,700 a year for VGS, with a range of $21,600 to $132,000. Vendr does not publish a purchase count or data date for that figure.
What TokenEx Charges
TokenEx and IXOPAY publish no price list, no starting price, and no billing unit on the pages we read. You request sandbox access through a form and a quote from sales. IXOPAY’s homepage says you pay for the capabilities and usage you need as you grow, so the price depends on which IXO One modules you take and on volume.
Capterra’s TokenEx listing shows a starting price of $1,000, as of 22 November 2026; we found no TokenEx or IXOPAY page that states a price, so treat it as a third-party figure and confirm it in a quote. Ask IXOPAY for a written quote that separates tokenization, orchestration, intelligence, and P2PE.
What Enigma Vault Charges
Every Card Vault tier is published. Lite is a free sandbox with 1,000 requests and 100 stored tokens for testing.
Starter is $49 a month for 20,000 requests (10,000 stored tokens), Growth is $249 for 250,000 (100,000 stored), and Business is $499 for 1,000,000 (1,000,000 stored).
Yearly prices are $550, $2,700, and $5,500, and overage is $0.02, $0.01, and $0.007 per request. Billing runs through the developer portal or AWS Marketplace.
VGS vs TokenEx Cost at Three Business Sizes
| Business size | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small team storing up to 10,000 cards | From $12,000 a year at the Starter floor | Quote; sandbox by request | $0 on Lite to test; $550 a year on Starter |
| Growing company storing about 100,000 cards | Growth, by quote; Vendr’s median is $56,700 a year | Quote, varies by modules | $2,700 a year on Growth |
| Established merchant routing across processors | Routing not sold; build or buy elsewhere | Orchestration module in IXO One, by quote | $5,500 a year on Business; routing not offered |
| Next step | VGS publishes only its floor and TokenEx publishes no prices, so ask both for a written quote at your volume. | ||
How to Read This Table: VGS does not publish its billing unit, TokenEx publishes no price at all, and Enigma Vault bills on requests with a stored-token limit on each tier, so the units are not identical. Use the table for order of magnitude, and remember that Enigma Vault’s price covers fewer payments features and no routing.
The Practical Takeaway: VGS is the only one of the two you can budget before a call, and its floor puts a first year at $12,000 or more. TokenEx can only be priced through IXOPAY sales.
Ask each for a written quote at your volume, including renewal and overage terms, and compare it with the published Enigma Vault price. See our list of the best credit card tokenization software for more price points.
Does VGS Compare Itself to TokenEx?
Not by name. VGS publishes a comparison of VGS against “other independent vaults”, and its table puts VGS in one column and an unnamed “Other Vaults” column in the other. TokenEx is never mentioned, but as an independent vault it falls inside that group, so the claims are worth checking against TokenEx’s own pages.
The page compares eight factors. These are the ones that bear most on a TokenEx decision:
- Direct network connections: VGS says it connects directly to Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover, and that other vaults “often go through 3rd parties.” TokenEx’s Universal Tokens page lists network token provisioning but does not say whether its connections are direct, so ask IXOPAY which networks it connects to itself.
- Reliability: VGS cites four-nines availability, multi-region disaster recovery, active-active deployment, and cell-based isolation. It says other vault customers “often come to VGS for redundancy after costly outages,” with no named example.
- Complex migrations: VGS claims bulk card migrations, with VGS Compute (its Larky language) for custom logic, and says other vaults have less experience with high-volume moves.
- Enterprise customers: VGS says other vaults “are focused on long-tail and SMB.” That does not fit TokenEx, whose homepage shows enterprise client logos and which now sits inside IXOPAY, an orchestration platform that says it has orchestrated $200B in transactions.
- Integrated payment products: VGS points to one Card Management Platform API for network tokens, account updater, account validation, 3DS, and card attributes. IXOPAY’s answer is orchestration across 500+ adapters, which is a different kind of integration.
- Support: VGS describes a dedicated account manager, solutions architect, and project manager, with 24/7 coverage, and says other vaults have “limited full-time support.”
The page also lists headline figures: 10B+ tokens stored, 10B+ monthly interactions, zero security breaches, and 250K+ requests per minute at Black Friday peaks. It repeats VGS’s PCI DSS Level 1, SOC 2 Type 2, and ISO 27001 certifications and its Visa and Mastercard service provider listings. All of these are VGS’s own claims, with no third-party source on the page.
IXOPAY’s Universal Tokens page contrasts its tokens with processor-issued tokens that only work with one processor; it does not mention VGS. Treat both vendors’ positioning as marketing, and count only the claims you can test in a proof of concept.
VGS vs TokenEx Reviews
VGS has 47 reviews on G2 at 4.7/5, and TokenEx has 17 at 4.6/5, listed as TokenEx (IXOPAY). Both have Capterra listings with no reviews. Enigma Vault has 6 on G2 and 4 on Capterra.
| Source | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| G2 | 4.7/5 from 47 reviews | 4.6/5 from 17 reviews | 4.4/5 from 6 reviews |
| Capterra | Listed, no reviews | Listed, no reviews | 4.8/5 from 4 reviews |
| Time to implement (G2 users) | About 4 months | About 1 month | Same-day sandbox |
| Next step | Six reviews is a thin base. Ask every vendor for a reference in your industry. | ||
What VGS Reviewers Say
VGS reviewers on G2 praise its support, especially chat, and how quickly they understood the proxy. The critical notes cluster around price and polish: cost on the high side, a $40 fee for each extra custom domain (CNAME), documentation that is out of date in places, and log filtering that could be better.
What TokenEx Reviewers Say
TokenEx reviewers like its Transparent Gateway, an easy API, a non-production region for testing, and quick responses to tickets. The main complaint is reporting, including usage history that stops at 30 days. Many reviews predate the IXO One branding, so they speak to the tokenization product more than to orchestration.
What Enigma Vault Reviewers Say
Enigma Vault reviewers describe a developer-friendly tokenization service that has worked without issues, and ask for lower pricing and more documentation. Six reviews is a thin base, so ask each vendor for a reference in your industry.
Who Should Choose VGS, TokenEx, or Enigma Vault
Payments Fintechs That Keep Routing In-House
VGS fits best. An independent vault lets you change routing without moving cards, and network tokens, account updater, card attributes, VGS Compute, and audit help sit in one Growth package. Expect a $1,000-a-month floor and a quote for Growth.
If You Run Several Acquirers Across Countries
TokenEx fits best. IXO One sells routing, retries, and approval-rate data across 250+ acquirers alongside the vault, and its homepage client logos include Aer Lingus, Siemens, and Zappos. Expect to price it through IXOPAY sales.
Retailers With Stores and an Online Shop
TokenEx fits best here too. IXOPAY’s PCI-validated P2PE covers the terminal side, so the same customer token works online and in store, and Zappos, Orvis, and Sennheiser appear on TokenEx’s client list. VGS lists no card-present product.
Smaller Merchants Who Want Published Prices and a Free Start
VGS’s sandbox is not for real card data, and TokenEx’s sandbox comes by request. Enigma Vault’s free Lite tier is also a sandbox for testing, but it publishes every paid tier, from $49 a month, and adds Twilio Pay IVR from Growth for cards that arrive by phone, so you can price your own volume before talking to anyone.
Questions to Ask VGS and TokenEx Before You Sign
Bring these to both vendors. The answers shown are what each publishes today, so you can see where a sales call is needed.
| Question | VGS | TokenEx | Also considerEnigma Vault |
|---|---|---|---|
| What will year one cost? | Starter from $1,000/mo; ask what Starter covers and what needs Growth | Quote only; ask which IXO One modules it includes | Published: $0, $49, $249, or $499 a month |
| Can we buy tokenization without orchestration? | Yes; VGS sells no orchestration | Ask for a tokenization-only quote | Yes; no orchestration sold |
| What is the billing unit and overage? | Not published | Not published | Requests; overage published |
| Which card networks are covered for network tokens? | Ask for coverage by network | Ask for coverage by network | Not offered |
| Can we see current compliance reports? | Request via Trust Center | Ask the vendor | AOC and SOC 2 report from Starter |
| How do we leave? | Ask for the export process in writing | Ask for the export process in writing | Ask for the export process in writing |
| Next step | Put the same questions to Enigma Vault. | ||
The last row matters for all three. Tokens never transfer between vaults on their own, and with TokenEx your tokens and routing may sit with one vendor, so agree the exit process before you sign.
Moving From VGS or TokenEx to Enigma Vault
A move is practical when you mainly use the vault and proxy, and harder when you rely on orchestration, P2PE, or network tokens. Plan it before you cancel anything.
- Agree the Card Migration: Cards move directly between PCI-compliant providers, with your acquirer involved.
- Plan for What Stays: Routing, retries, P2PE, network tokens, and account updater need another home or your gateway.
- Re-Tokenize Stored References: VGS aliases and TokenEx Universal Tokens will not work in a new vault, so map old references to new tokens.
- Run Both for a Few Weeks: Write to both, reconcile, then cut over.
Our guide to migrating tokenization providers has a checklist for running two vaults side by side. If you want help mapping what you store, book a migration call.
Final Verdict: VGS, TokenEx, or Enigma Vault?
VGS and TokenEx are built for different buyers. VGS is the stronger choice when you want the vault to be its own product, independent of routing, with network tokens, account updater, VGS Compute, and audit help from one vendor.
TokenEx is the stronger choice when you want IXOPAY to run tokenization and routing together, especially across many acquirers, in stores, or with PII and PHI in the same vault.
I’d decide who should own routing first and the price second, and I’d get a written quote with overage and renewal terms from either one before you commit.
If you want published prices, a free start, and phone card capture, Enigma Vault’s Card Vault covers those. It has no network tokens, account updater, routing, or P2PE, so if your project depends on any of them, it is not the right choice.
Compare against your actual card volume.
Book a demo and we will tell you honestly whether VGS, TokenEx, or Enigma Vault fits, or explore Card Vault first.
More comparisons: Enigma Vault vs VGS, Enigma Vault vs TokenEx, VGS vs Basis Theory, and VGS vs Evervault.
How We Researched This Comparison
We rechecked vendor facts on 22 November 2026. VGS facts come from verygoodsecurity.com, including its pricing page, its comparison page, and its Trust Center.
TokenEx facts come from tokenex.com and ixopay.com, including the homepage and the Universal Tokens, P2PE, account updater, and BIN lookup pages; IXOPAY’s security page returned a 404 on 22 November 2026, so we list its certifications as not published.
Vendr figures and G2 and Capterra reviews and listings are third-party, read on 22 November 2026, and Enigma Vault facts come from our own pricing and product pages.
Where a vendor makes a claim about itself or a rival, such as PCI scope reduction or reliability, we label it as a vendor claim. If something here is out of date, tell us through our contact page and we will check it.